Should DSOs Be Led by Dentists?

Should DSOs Be Led by Dentists?

The CEO debate reshaping corporate dentistry


Dentistry has officially joined the big leagues of corporate health care, and with that comes a question many keep circling back to: If you own and manage a chain of dental offices, should you actually be a dentist? Today, some of the largest DSOs in the country are run by CEOs without dental degrees. Pacific Dental Services is led by Stephen Thorne, who is not a dentist. Heartland Dental’s CEO, Patrick Bauer, is not a dentist. Smile Brands is headed by Steve Bilt, also not a dentist. This reality alone sparks heated debate.

This feels strange. Dentistry is not retail. It is not coffee or clothing. The product is judgment, ethics, and trust. You only understand that pressure when you have lived inside an operatory, handled complications, and had difficult conversations with patients. A pure business executive may be great at scaling systems and managing spreadsheets, but without clinical DNA, it is easy to optimize for EBITDA instead of outcomes. That is how production quotas appear, appointments get rushed, and doctors burn out.

If dentists are not at the top of the decision-making hierarchy, the entire organization risks drifting away from patient care toward pure profit. Health care is not forgiving when leadership loses touch with the craft.

Legally, the situation is messy. In most states, only licensed dentists can own a dental practice because of the corporate practice of dentistry doctrine. A handful of states allow non-dentists to own practices outright. Everywhere else, DSOs operate through management companies that handle billing, HR, marketing, and back-office systems, while dentists technically retain ownership and clinical authority. On paper, the dentist is in charge. In real life, contracts often tell a more complicated story.

The ADA does not mandate that DSOs have dentist CEOs. Instead, it stresses one core principle: Dentists must retain clinical control. Their guidance repeatedly warns that contracts can quietly strip autonomy. Long-term non-compete clauses and forced buy-sell agreements can trap doctors. If you sign a DSO contract without a health care attorney, you are gambling with your career.

Internationally, Europe faces the same struggle. The Council of European Dentists openly worries about treatment quotas and loss of autonomy inside corporate chains. Their stance is clear: Dentists should remain central to decision-making, even when corporations own the practices. The UK has allowed corporate dentistry for more than a century, but regulators still require licensed dentists to oversee patient care.

Dentists also draw parallels to other industries. Boeing moved from engineer CEOs to finance leaders and shifted its headquarters away from its engineering base. Quality collapsed. Theranos, WeWork, FTX, and Uber all followed the same pattern. Leaders who did not understand the core product made catastrophic decisions. When leadership loses touch with the craft, spreadsheets replace reality. Reality always wins.

The takeaway is not that DSOs are evil. Some dentists thrive in them. New grads like the structure. Older docs like escaping ownership headaches. Patients like extended hours and convenience. The model must work for many since about 20% of U.S. dental practices are owned by or affiliated with a DSO.

But dentists say the danger is subtle. It starts when business metrics outrank clinical judgment.

Ultimately, dentistry only works when trust comes first. Whether the CEO is a dentist or not matters less than whether dentists truly run the clinical side. If that ever becomes window dressing, the profession pays the price.

Would you ever work for or sell to a DSO where no dentists sit in real positions of power?

Join the Conversation!


Sponsors
Townie Perks
Townie® Poll
Do you still use film?
  
The Dentaltown Team, Farran Media Support
Phone: +1-480-445-9710
Email: support@dentaltown.com
©2026 Dentaltown, a division of Farran Media • All Rights Reserved
9633 S. 48th Street Suite 200 • Phoenix, AZ 85044 • Phone:+1-480-598-0001 • Fax:+1-480-598-3450