Dental A Team with Kiera Dent
Dental A Team with Kiera Dent
Dentists, this is your playbook for building a practice that THRIVES rather than just survives! If you're ready to scale, streamline, or simply want to lead like a CEO, we're here to support you with our strategies.
Blog By:
Dental A Team
Dental A Team

SharePostShareShare
Dental Team Accountability: Would You Rehire Them?

Dental Team Accountability: Would You Rehire Them?

10/19/2026 6:57:00 AM   |   Comments: 0   |   Views: 82
Imagine every position in your dental practice became vacant tomorrow.

Knowing what is known today, would every current team member be hired back into the same role?

That question can make even experienced practice owners uncomfortable. There are people who have been with the practice for years, employees who feel like family, and team members who have been through difficult seasons alongside the doctor.

But dental team accountability requires an honest look at more than loyalty and history.

The purpose of asking whether someone would be rehired is not to start looking for people to replace. It is to determine whether the practice has the right roles, clear expectations, effective coaching, and a team that can support where the business is headed.

Sometimes the answer reveals a performance problem. Sometimes it reveals a leadership problem. And occasionally, it reveals that a great person is sitting in the wrong position.

Dental Team Accountability Starts With the Leader

Before evaluating the team, practice owners need to evaluate what has changed.

Maybe the practice added an associate. Maybe hygiene expanded, the schedule became more demanding, or the front office went from two people to five.

The same team structure that supported the practice three years ago may not support its next stage of growth.

That does not automatically mean someone has become a poor employee.

The role may have changed without anyone clearly explaining the new expectations.

Before deciding whether an employee is meeting the standard, the doctor should be able to explain what that standard is.

What does success look like in the position today? What responsibilities belong to that person? What training has been provided? And has the employee been given a reasonable opportunity to meet the current expectations?

Those answers matter because accountability is difficult when the expectations keep moving.

Build the Org Chart Around the Practice, Not the People

One of the most common leadership mistakes in dentistry is building positions around whoever happens to be available.

A longtime front office employee becomes responsible for billing because that person has always handled it. An assistant becomes the lead assistant because of tenure. Someone who is excellent with patients gets assigned administrative responsibilities that require a completely different set of strengths.

Eventually, the practice grows, and those arrangements stop working.

The solution is to design the organizational chart around what the practice needs before deciding who should fill each position.

Consider a small dental office where one front desk employee originally handled scheduling, confirmations, insurance, and billing.

As the practice grows, those duties may need to become separate roles with greater accountability.

The employee who was excellent at handling everything in a smaller practice might be far more effective managing patient relationships than spending the entire day working insurance claims.

That is not necessarily a performance failure.

It may be a sign that the practice has outgrown its original role design.

Dental Team Accountability Needs More Than a Gut Feeling

An employee misses a deadline. The schedule has openings. Insurance follow-up is behind. Another team member complains about unfinished work.

It is easy for a frustrated owner to turn those situations into conclusions about the person.

But measurable results should enter the conversation before emotions take over.

If the scheduling coordinator is struggling, review the scheduling goals, confirmation process, open treatment, and follow-up activity.

If billing is behind, look at accounts receivable, claim follow-up, and whether responsibilities are being completed consistently.

The numbers help identify what is happening.

They do not automatically explain why.

An employee missing a KPI could need additional training, clearer processes, more support, or a different workload. There could also be a genuine performance issue that needs correction.

The important distinction is that leaders investigate the gap rather than immediately labeling the employee.

Can They Do the Job, and Do They Want It?

When performance falls short, three questions can change the direction of the conversation.

Does the team member know how to perform the responsibilities?

Does the person genuinely want the role?

And does that employee have the capacity and support to do the work well?

A knowledge gap calls for training.

A capacity problem may require better systems, clearer priorities, or a review of how responsibilities are assigned.

A mismatch between the person and the position may require a different conversation.

Not every responsibility has to be enjoyable. Every dental position includes tasks that are repetitive, uncomfortable, or less exciting than others.

The concern is when the core responsibilities of a position consistently conflict with the employee's abilities or willingness to perform them.

Someone can be a talented team member without being suited to every job in the practice.

The goal is not to design a position around every personal preference. It is to determine whether the employee can succeed in a role the practice genuinely needs.

Core Values Give Dental Team Accountability a Standard

Performance is not only about completing tasks.

A team member might consistently meet production or scheduling goals while creating unnecessary conflict with coworkers. Another employee may be friendly and well-liked but repeatedly fail to follow through on commitments.

Neither situation should be ignored.

Core values give practice owners a way to evaluate how employees contribute to the culture, not just the results they produce.

If the practice values teamwork, does the employee support coworkers when the schedule becomes difficult?

If accountability is a core value, does that person accept feedback and take responsibility when something goes wrong?

If patient experience matters, does the employee demonstrate that commitment even when the office is busy?

These evaluations should be based on observable behaviors rather than personality preferences.

A quiet employee is not necessarily disengaged. Someone who asks difficult questions is not automatically a poor cultural fit.

The relevant issue is whether the person's actions consistently support the standards the practice has established.

A Frustrating Week Is Not the Whole Story

Dental offices are busy environments, and the pressure does not affect every employee the same way.

A usually dependable assistant may suddenly seem distracted. A front office employee who normally communicates well may become short with coworkers.

Those changes deserve attention, but not an immediate verdict about the person's character.

A leader who knows the team can recognize when something is different.

That requires regular conversations, not just rushed feedback between patients or a meeting after something goes wrong.

Sometimes an employee is overwhelmed. Sometimes the workload has shifted. Sometimes a team member has been struggling with a particular responsibility without knowing how to ask for help.

Those conversations do not eliminate the need for accountability.

They provide the information needed to make a better decision.

Dental Team Accountability Improves With Regular One-on-Ones

How can dentists hold their teams accountable without micromanaging?

Establish clear expectations, check in consistently, and make sure both the leader and employee understand what improvement looks like.

Monthly one-on-ones can be an effective rhythm for many practices. Larger offices may rotate departments and meet with each employee quarterly.

The exact schedule matters less than consistency.

These meetings should create space to discuss performance, obstacles, support, and professional growth.

If a KPI is being missed, the conversation should identify the gap and determine what needs to happen next.

Perhaps the employee needs additional training. Maybe a system is missing. Perhaps expectations have not been clearly communicated.

The discussion should end with specific action items and a plan for follow-up.

Consistent conversations also build trust. Employees should understand where they stand long before a serious performance decision is necessary.

A difficult conversation may still be emotional, but the subject should not come as a complete surprise.

Dental Team Accountability Means Giving Coaching a Fair Chance

A struggling employee should not automatically be considered a lost cause.

People can improve. Skills can be developed. Employees can become more confident and capable when leaders invest in training and offer useful feedback.

The important word is intentional.

Coaching needs to address a specific problem and create a reasonable opportunity for improvement.

For example, an employee who consistently misses insurance follow-up expectations may need to review the process, demonstrate the required skills, and work toward a defined performance goal.

The leader can then assess whether the coaching is producing meaningful change.

Repeating the same conversation without changing the support, expectations, or follow-up does not create progress.

Neither does continuing indefinitely because the owner feels guilty about making a difficult decision.

Good coaching gives people a genuine opportunity to succeed while recognizing that the practice also has responsibilities to patients and the rest of the team.

Sometimes the Right Answer Is a Different Seat

There are situations where an employee is valued by the practice but no longer fits the role.

That does not always mean the working relationship has to end.

A team member may be better suited to patient communication than insurance billing. Someone who struggles in a leadership position may be an excellent individual contributor.

When a suitable position exists, a role change may allow the practice to retain a valuable employee while improving performance.

There are also situations where an honest conversation helps both sides recognize that the practice and employee are heading in different directions.

In one dental practice, a team member recognized that the office's growth and evolving expectations were no longer the right fit. Because communication and trust had been established, the employee was able to discuss the situation openly, help identify a potential replacement, and support the transition.

Not every departure will happen that smoothly.

The lesson is that clear direction and respectful communication can make difficult changes healthier for everyone involved.

Dental Team Accountability Protects the Whole Team

Keeping someone in the wrong role does not affect only that employee.

Other team members may be quietly compensating for missed responsibilities. They stay late to complete unfinished work, handle difficult patient conversations, or repeatedly correct preventable mistakes.

Over time, that can create resentment.

The doctor may believe that keeping the employee demonstrates loyalty, while the rest of the team sees that expectations are not being applied consistently.

That is why the rehire question is ultimately a leadership question.

Has the employee received clear expectations and appropriate support? Have performance concerns been discussed directly? Is there a realistic path to improvement or another suitable role?

If the answer is still that the person is not the right fit, leadership may need to make a change through the appropriate employment process.

That decision does not mean the employee is a bad person.

It means the current arrangement is not serving the practice, the individual, or the team.

The healthiest dental cultures are not built by avoiding uncomfortable conversations. They are built when leaders care enough to coach, communicate, uphold standards, and make thoughtful decisions.

Before asking whether every employee would be rehired, practice owners should ask whether every employee has been given the clarity, training, feedback, and opportunity needed to succeed.

Then the rehire question becomes much more useful.

It stops being a reaction to frustration and becomes a way to evaluate the strength of the practice's leadership, culture, and team structure.

Dental A Team helps practice owners strengthen team accountability, leadership conversations, and role clarity through practical coaching and systems. If your practice needs help assessing team fit without guessing or micromanaging, schedule a call with our team.

For more tips, check out our podcast.

Clients see up to a 30% increase in revenue

Last updated: October, 2026
Category: Ethics, Jurisprudence and Malpractice, Office Design, Practice Management, HR and Accounting
SharePostShareShare
You must be logged in to view comments.
More In Ethics, Jurisprudence and Malpractice
Howard Speaks: Inside the American Dental Association—A Call for Transparency and Reform
Howard Speaks: Inside the American Dental Association—A Call for...
by Dr. Howard Farran, DDS, MBA
June 2025
Patient Threatening to Sue for Work Done at Previous Practice
Patient Threatening to Sue for Work Done at Previous Practice
February 2025
Risk Management and Record Keeping.
Risk Management and Record Keeping.
Mr. Jeff Tonner
CE Credits: 2
The Ultimate Guide to Dentistry’s Standard of Care, Part 3
The Ultimate Guide to Dentistry’s Standard of Care, Part 3
Dr. John Dovgan
CE Credits: 2.5
More In Office Design
Budget Musts
Budget Musts
by Dr. Kha Nguyen
September 2025
Stacking the Tech
Stacking the Tech
Reuben Kamp
CE Credits: 1.5
Tech, Trust, and Teamwork
Tech, Trust, and Teamwork
November 2025
The Floor Plan is Key to Productivity: Floor Plan Analysis to Ensure Great Results
The Floor Plan is Key to Productivity: Floor Plan Analysis to...
Dr. Mark Tholen
CE Credits: 1.5
More In Practice Management, HR and Accounting
Creating a Remarkable Dental Practice: Advertising and Tracking
Creating a Remarkable Dental Practice: Advertising and Tracking
Fred Joyal
CE Credits: 1.5
Howard Speaks: Reassessing Dentistry’s ‘Villains’
Howard Speaks: Reassessing Dentistry’s ‘Villains’
by Dr. Howard Farran, DDS, MBA
March 2024
The Invincible Dental Practice... Filmed Live at Townie Meeting.
The Invincible Dental Practice... Filmed Live at Townie Meeting.
Fred Joyal
CE Credits: 1.5
What Women Dentists Really Wear to Work
What Women Dentists Really Wear to Work
July 2025
Total Blog Activity
997
Total Bloggers
13,451
Total Blog Posts
4,671
Total Podcasts
1,788
Total Videos
Dentaltown Magazine
October 2026
Dentaltown Magazine October 2026 Read Current Issue Read Archived Issues
Sponsors
Townie Perks
Townie® Poll
Who or what do you turn to for most financial advice regarding your practice?