Perio
Reports Vol. 22 No. 12 |
Perio Reports provides easy-to-read research summaries on topics of specific interest to clinicians.
Perio Reports research summaries will be included in each issue to keep you on the cutting edge
of dental hygiene science.
|
Caries and Perio Found Together
With studies showing caries and
periodontitis found together and
other studies showing either one disease
or the other, research is contradictory.
Both are bacterial in nature,
impacted by the accumulation of
bacterial biofilm. It is suspected that
salivary pH might contribute to disease
selection, with an acid pH leading
to more caries and a basic pH
contributing to calculus formation
and periodontitis. Research hasn't evaluated this theory.
Researchers from the University of Oulu in Finland compared
the incidence of both caries and periodontal disease in a group of
5,000 adults older than age 30 who were part of a national health
survey. Clinical examinations were conducted by five field teams in
community settings using a headlamp for light, a mouth mirror, a
periodontal probe and explorer. Compressed air was available to
dry teeth prior to examination.
The deepest probing depth for each tooth was recorded in
one of three categories: none, 4-5mm or 6mm. Dental caries
were recorded if cavitation was present and the lesion was
extending into the dentin.
Of this group, 65 percent had 4mm probing depths; 21 percent
had 6mm probing depths; and 29 percent had dental caries. The
caries incidence was significantly lower than reported for the UK or
the U.S. Perhaps the use of xylitol in Finland is responsible.
In the group with 6mm probing depths, 44 percent also had
caries. In the periodontally healthy group, 23 percent had caries.
More severe periodontal disease and caries tend to be found in the
same patients.
Clinical Implications: Observe your patients to see how often
they present with both caries and periodontal disease.
Mattila, P., Niskanen, M., Vehkalahti, M., Nordblad, A., Knuuttila,
M.: Prevalence and Simultaneous Occurrences of Periodontitis and
Dental Caries. J Clin Perio 37: 962-967, 2010. |
|
Vitamin B12 and Folate Prevent
Aphthous Ulcers
Recurrent aphthous stomatitis (RAS) is a widespread,
common oral mucousal lesion. Incidence levels
vary with reports as high as 50 percent in women
and 40 percent in men. The lesions are small, oval in
shape with necrotic tissue in the center and a red
inflamed border. The lesions are painful, especially
with eating and regular oral hygiene. RAS is more
common in younger people than older people. This
difference might be explained by dietary intake of
nutrients. Younger people are less likely to eat healthy,
well balance meals than older people.
Researchers at the University of Connecticut in
Farmington analyzed the dietary intake of 100 subjects
who experienced at least three episodes of RAS in
the past year. These findings were compared to
age- and gender-matched participants in the U.S.
National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey
(NHANES). Dietary intake was evaluated using
DietCalc software that calculates specific nutrients
based on the reported food intake. This allowed daily
nutrient comparisons between the two groups.
Nine nutrients were identified for comparison:
vitamins A, B6, B12, C, E, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin
and folate. Those in the RAS group had higher levels
of seven of the nine nutrients than the controls. The
two nutrients that were lower in this group were vitamin
B12 and folate. This correlates to seven percent of
the recommended daily intake level for vitamin B12
and 20 percent of the recommended level for folate.
Just how vitamin deficiencies affect RAS is unknown.
Clinical Implications: Increasing dietary B12 and
folate or adding nutritional supplements seems an
easy way to prevent recurrent aphthous ulcers.
Kozlak, S., Walsh, S., Lalla, R.: Reduced Dietary
Intake of Vitamin B12 and Folate in Patients with
Recurrent Aphthous Stomatitis. J Oral Pathol Med 39:
420-423, 2010. |
|
|
Systemic Markers After SRP and SX
Periodontal infection is associated with several systemic
inflammatory markers. Low-grade systemic inflammation is
evident by increased concentrations of biomarkers including
C-reactive protein (CRP), leucocyte counts, serum amyloid-A
and other blood markers.
Researchers at the University of Pisa in Italy monitored
these serum inflammatory markers at baseline, and days
seven, 30, 90 and 180 following SRP. They were also monitored
after flap surgery out to day 270. The 14 study subjects
all had chronic moderate periodontitis. Baseline
probing depths revealed an average of 64 pockets measuring
4mm or more per patient. Patients all received baseline
data collection, oral hygiene instructions and full-mouth
SRP completed within 24 hours. Pockets were reduced at
three months to 16 and by six months to 15. Surgery was
done in two sessions after the six-month visit and resulted
in further pocket depth reductions to eight pockets per
patient on average.
CRP levels increased after the SRP visit and to a lesser
level after each surgery. Other serum markers also showed
more significant increases after SRP, with much smaller
impacts after the two surgeries. This is most likely attributed
to the fact that full-mouth
SRP was done when the
area of periodontal infection
was considerably larger
than the areas undergoing
localized surgery. The
extent of periodontal infection
influences the changes
in inflammatory markers
following treatment more
than the particular treatment
provided.
Clinical Implications: These results are no surprise to clinicians,
and these findings add to research supporting
what you experience clinically.
Kumar, S., Phoophalia, A., Tibdewal, H., Tadakamadla, J.,
Duraiswamy, P., Kulkarni, S.: Oral Malodour: Its Association
with Tongue Coating and Periodontal Disease. Dental Health
49: 5 and 6, 6-9, 2010. |
|
C-reactive Protein Produced Systemically
Periodontitis, as well as other systemic diseases are associated
with elevated levels of C-reactive protein (CRP) measured in
both serum and gingival crevicular fluid (GCF). Treatment of
periodontitis reduces CRP levels.
CRP is produced by the liver in response to inflammation or
tissue necrosis. Even mild serum levels of CRP are evidence of a
tissue damaging process going on somewhere in the body.
Recent research shows evidence that CRP can be produced in
small amounts by cells other than hepatic cells. Based on these
findings, researchers at the University of Adelaide in South
Australia wondered if CRP might originate in gingival and periodontal
tissues as well as systemically from the liver.
If CRP is synthesized in gingival tissues, signs of mRNA
would be present in tissue samples. Tissue samples were collected
from patients undergoing periodontal surgery and from
periodontally healthy patients undergoing crown lengthening or
who allowed a tissue biopsy prior to tooth extraction. GCF samples
were also collected and analyzed.
Tissue samples were collected from 46 subjects with periodontal
disease and 13 periodontally healthy subjects. GCF flow
in those with periodontal disease was double that of the healthy
subjects. Polymerase chain reaction was used to determine if
CRP was manufactured within gingival tissue. No evidence of
mRNA was found in the tissue samples. The authors conclude
that CRP measured in GCF is indicative of systemic inflammation,
either periodontal disease or infection somewhere else in
the body.
Clinical
Implications: Chairside kits are being developed
that have the potential to provide an alternative to blood
tests for measuring systemic CRP that might reflect systemic
inflammation.
Megson, E., Fitzsimmons, T., Dharmapatni, K., Bartold, M.: CReactive
Protein in Gingival Crevicular Fluid May be Indicative of
Systemic Inflammation. J Clin Perio 37: 797-804, 2010. |
|
Oral Cancer Screening Devices Compared
In 2008, oral cancer cases numbered 35,000, with 7,500 deaths. ViziLite Plus with
TBlue and the VELscope were developed to enhance oral cancer screening exams in the
hope of identifying lesions not readily seen by clinicians.
Researchers at Moti Lal Nehru Medical
College in India compared two diagnostic light
systems, ViziLite Plus and VELscope. The study
took place at a rural district hospital in central
India. A total of 258 patients were examined
using an overhead dental light and found to have
clinically innocuous lesions that the examiners
decided required no further attention other than
routine follow-up. Subjects were randomly
assigned to examination with either the ViziLite
Plus system or the VELscope. All subjects then
underwent surgical biopsies.
The ViziLite system was used on 102 subjects.
Biopsies revealed one mild dysplasia, two
moderate dysplasias and one cancer. None were
correctly identified by the ViziLite or the clinicians.
ViziLite correctly identified 74 out of 98
benign lesions as negative. Incorrectly identified
as positive were 24 benign lesions.
The VELscope was used on 156 subjects.
Tissue biopsies revealed 11 dysplasias, and one
cancer. The VELscope correctly identified five
dysplasias and the cancer, thus half were correctly
identified by the VELscope. The VELscope
correctly identified 56 of 144 negative findings
and six of the 12 positive findings. Eighty-eight
VELscope positives were actually benign.
Clinical Implications: Identifying precancerous
and cancerous lesions is difficult for clinicians,
and the VELscope appears to provide
benefit in identifying cancer, but also identifies
as positive lesions that are not cancer.
Doing an oral cancer screening examination
on every patient is essential.
Mehrotra, R., Singh, M., Thomas, S., et al: A
Cross-Sectional Study Evaluating Chemiluminescence
and Autofluorescence in the Detection
of Clinically Innocuous Precancerous and
Cancerous Oral Lesions. JADA 141: 151-
156, 2010. |
|
Antibiotics for Third Molar Extraction
Prescribing antibiotics to prevent infection resulting from third
molar extractions is a topic of considerable debate. In 2007 the
American Heart Association issued new antibiotic prophylaxis guidelines
based on current evidence of the risks associated with antibiotic overuse.
Adverse reactions to the drugs and development of drug-resistant bacteria
are greater risks than infection.
Researchers at the University of Otago, in Dunedin, New Zealand
compared impacted third molar extractions in the same patient with and
without antibiotic prophylaxis. Ninety-five patients were divided into
two groups and each served as their own control, receiving the assigned
antibiotic dose for one surgery and a placebo for the other surgery.
Group one received 1g of amoxicillin one hour before surgery. In addition,
group two also received 500mg of amoxicillin every eight hours for
two days after surgery.
No significant differences were observed between test and placebo
groups for pain, swelling, temperature or trismus. Post-operative
infections occurred in just six cases or two percent of the 380 extractions.
Three dry sockets were reported in the placebo group and one
in the group receiving one dose of amoxicillin. In the group receiving
multiple doses of amoxicillin, one patient experienced a dry socket
after both the antibiotic and the placebo. Differences between the
groups were not significant as the overall rate of post-operative infection
was so low.
Clinical
Implications: Each case must be evaluated individually,
however the risks associated with taking antibiotics seem to outweigh
the risks due to infection after extractions.
Siddiqi, A., Morkel, A., Zafar, S.: Antibiotic Prophylaxis in Third
Molar Surgery: A Randomized Double-Blind Placebo-Controlled
Clinical Trial Using Split-Mouth Technique. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg
39: 107-114, 2010. |
|