Consider these two alternate scenarios:
It all started here! Prior to the engineering stage, my
architect and dental equipment consultant created a
custom “dental equipment specification sheet.” This
sheet became part of my official construction documents
that went out to the contractors to bid. When
the contractor was finished with my project, the final
payout was virtually identical to the original bid
quoted to me. I was able to stay within my budget and
protect my working capital.
or...
It all started here! My architect and dental equipment
consultant “dropped the ball.” They were lax on
providing the engineers for my project the necessary
written detailed equipment information. As a result,
many equipment requirements were missing from my
construction documents. This lack of detail created a
never-ending parade of change orders during tenant
improvements, and my construction costs spiraled out
of control. When the contractor was finished with my
project, the final payout was much higher than the original
bid quoted to me. I was well over my budget, and
my available working capital shrunk dramatically.
Unfortunately, the second scenario happens all too
often in the dental industry. The industry’s lack in providing
the architect’s engineers with detailed written dental
equipment requirements is the single biggest flaw in the
process of opening a new dental office. Not having complete
control of the engineering phase in your project
will adversely affect your budget. There are only two
people who can provide this written information for the
engineers. They are your dental equipment consultant
and your architect. That is why I recommended earlier
to spend a little more money up front and hire the companies
willing to create a custom dental equipment
specification sheet for you. They will save you many
times the cost of this investment, as well as time delays
and complications.
The more you understand how the process usually
unfolds to create the unfortunate second scenario, the
better prepared you’ll be to prevent it from happening
to you. [Editor’s note: Refer to the book here! Before
we go any further, go to your appendix and find the
2’ x 3’ sample of a custom “dental equipment specification
sheet.” It is similar to what you will want to be
included in your construction documents. This is what must be completed before the engineering phase begins
and before the construction documents go out to bid
to the contractors.] (Note: This sample plan is for a
medical/dental/teaching facility. The reception area,
waiting room, bathrooms and storage rooms, which
are shared, are located in another part of the building).
I personally create a specification sheet like this for my
clients, then give it to the architect to print and include
in the construction documents. If you do not have a
dental equipment consultant in your locale who can
create a custom specification sheet for you, at least you
can show your dental equipment sales representative
and your architect the sample to illustrate what you
expect from them. It takes money to make money, so
protect yourself by making the investment in this valuable
document. The dental equipment sales representative
and architect are going to earn their keep with the
extra effort and time it takes to create this custom dental
equipment specification sheet.
When I first got into the dental equipment business,
I felt frustrated at seeing my clients routinely
spend much more than they budgeted for their construction
costs. As is common practice in the dental
industry, after the space plan was signed off on with
the architect, I, as the dental equipment salesman,
would meet with the engineers to begin that phase of
the construction documents. Prior to the meeting, my
client and I had finalized the equipment list, I had
done all my homework and then reviewed all my
clients’ equipment requirements face-to-face with the
engineers. This meeting would last approximately two
hours, during which the engineers would feverishly
take notes on the equipment requirements as I spoke.
I’d leave the meeting feeling good about how it went
and looking forward to an accurate set of plans. The
engineers would promise to complete the engineering
phase in three weeks’ time, on average.
What I didn’t realize is that it only took the engineers
a few days to complete the engineering phase,
but they had asked for three weeks because they had
prior client commitments. When the three-week time
line approached, one of two things happened. If the
engineer who attended the meeting had the time, he
would personally complete the engineering phase.
However, he often forgot many of the intricate details
from the meeting that occurred two weeks before. Or,
even worse, if the engineer did not have the time to
complete the engineering phase himself, he would give
his notes to an assistant who wasn’t even at the meeting
to do it for him, which would result in an even
greater amount of missing information. When the
construction documents were completed, they then
would be sent out to the city for review and to the
contractors for bid. I’d look at my copy of the construction
documents and typically see listed on paper
a maximum of 70-75 percent of the dental equipment
requirements that we had discussed at the meeting. As
a result, my client was now vulnerable to a parade of
“change orders” during the construction phase.
I thought this weakness in the process might just be
unique to Arizona until I attended a new office design
course in North Carolina. The course was presented by
a nationally known architect who specialized in dental
offices, and a statement he made confirmed that this
inherent weakness in the process exists in the dental
equipment industry nationwide. The architect told the
audience that dentists should add an additional 25
percent to the costs given to them from the contractor
when planning their budget! He then went on to say
that many of the construction firms on the East Coast
have a full-time employee whose sole job description is
to scour construction documents for any areas where
they can obtain “change order” opportunities.
At first, I blamed the contractors. I approached
several of them and asked why they couldn’t be more
ethical and honest with dentists when providing a bid.
Their response was twofold, and they were right on
both fronts. They explained that if they were the only
contractor to include missing dental equipment
requirements in their bid, that they would run themselves
right out of business and never win a project.
What’s more, they felt it is the architect’s responsibility
to ensure all needed requirements were on paper,
because that is what the architect is being paid to do.
I then approached several architects and engineers
and told them the current process wasn’t working. When I asked them what they could do to clean the process up,
they threw it right back in my face! They said the dental
equipment industry is very lax on providing the engineers
with what they need to do an accurate job.
Engineers claim to get from dental equipment suppliers
few or no written requirements they can incorporate.
They often can’t get a return phone call when attempting
to get further information from the equipment salesman.
The engineers’ common theme was, “We do the
best we can under the circumstances.”
I asked them to show me exactly what they needed
from me, as the dental equipment salesman, to shore up
this inherent weakness and provide for an efficient and
complete disclosure of technical dental equipment information
in the construction documents. [Editor’s note:
Refer to the book here! Please unfold that sample custom
“dental equipment specification sheet” included in the
appendix of this text, and let’s go over in detail what the
engineers requested from me.] Start in the upper left
hand corner. The engineers wanted a detailed list of
every piece of dental equipment and dental manufactured
cabinetry going into a given office. It doesn’t matter
if the dentist is buying equipment new from a dental
equipment company, moving used equipment, or getting
it on eBay. The engineers need a complete list of all
items that will go into the new office either now or in the
future. Notice that every piece of equipment has an
assigned number, from 1-29, followed by the quantity. If
you look at the office space plan on the lower right of this
sheet, you’ll see that these assigned numbers have been
specifically placed at the exact location that you want
them in your office. This is important to the electrical
engineers, so they know exactly which outlet each piece
of equipment will plug into.
The mechanical engineer then requested nine vertical
columns to be included: cold water, hot water, drain, air,
vacuum, natural gas, nitrous oxide, oxygen and vent. Any
piece of equipment that requires any of these items
receives a check in the corresponding box. The electrical
engineer asked for the numbers of amps each piece of
equipment draws, as well as whether it requires a 110- or
220-volt circuit. Only if the engineer knows how many
amps an item draws and exactly which outlet it plugs into,
can he design an electric panel without overloading circuits.
The electrical engineer also requested columns indicating
whether specific equipment needed dedicated
circuits, low-voltage wiring, a remote switch and even any
unusual nema (plug) configurations. The “remarks” column
of the sheet include detailed descriptions that go over
and above what the bidding electricians and plumbers will
see in their corresponding pages in the construction documents.
The final columns were added by me to further
clarify not only who is responsible for providing, but also
who is responsible for installing every piece of equipment
and cabinetry going into your new office (even down to
such details as to who is responsible for caulking the side
sink cabinets after they have been installed).
It is very important that the engineers add a highlighted
comment on each of their respective mechanical,
plumbing, and electrical pages. This comment should
say something along the lines of, “Please refer to dental
equipment specification sheet for further dental equipment
requirements.” A highlighted comment is necessary
because often the contractors, in order to save
printing costs, will only send the electrical pages of your
construction documents to the electrician bidding on
your project. They often do the same with the mechanical
pages and the plumbing pages, each given to the
appropriate subcontractors. The highlighted comment
portion will alert the bidding subcontractors that there
may be additional equipment requirements that aren’t
addressed on their sheets, and they will then ask for them
from their contractor. Subcontractors will ask for these
requirements to protect themselves, because they understand
that if an equipment requirement is “on paper”
anywhere in the construction documents, they won’t be
able to approach the dentist with a change order.
Finally, in the upper right hand corner, you’ll see a
list of “Dental Equipment General Notes.” There are a
number of equipment requirements that require further
written clarification, and this is where you’ll find them.
If you take the time to read through these, you will also
see a trend that requires the electricians, plumbers and
contractor to “verify with equipment consultant” all dental equipment requirements in the field, before beginning
any equipment-related construction. Thorough
documentation puts the burden of responsibility on only
one person’s shoulders for a smooth and issue-free equipment
installation, and that person should be your dental
equipment consultant. Having only one person responsible
eliminates any “finger pointing” if the results end up
less that ideal.
Since implementing this custom “dental equipment
specification sheet,” I have seen the percentage of missing
dental equipment requirements in the construction documents
drop from the previous 25-30 percent to less than
10 percent. That’s still 10 percent too much! When you
find a dental equipment supplier and architect willing to
create this specification sheet, ask them to take the process
one step further by creating an addendum. I’ll explain.
Typically, when the engineers have finished their
piece and the architect has finished the design phase for
your new office, the finished set of construction documents
are sent to the city for review. As mentioned
before, it may take four to six weeks to receive initial city
comments. The bidding process, in contrast, usually
only takes about three weeks. Here is how your dental
equipment consultant can further help control your
construction costs: When my client’s architect is ready to
send the finished set of construction documents to the
city for review, I (as dental equipment consultant) ask
him to delay sending them out to bid until I have a
chance to review the plans one last time. It only takes me
a couple of days to go over the mechanical, electric and
plumbing pages thoroughly looking for any remaining
omissions, discrepancies, or errors in the dental equipment
requirements. Many engineers will welcome this
additional help to refine their work and will gladly spend
the additional time (about one week) making the necessary
corrections. If not, have your dental equipment
consultant meet with the architect and create a list
(“addendum”) of these remaining missing requirements.
The addendum will now become part of the official construction
documents that will be sent to the contractors
for bid. The beauty of this extra step is that you can gain
added protection without delaying your project, since
the contractor’s bids will still be completed before you
hear from the city planners with their initial comments
or building permit.
Holding a thoroughly prepared custom “dental
equipment specification sheet” and an addendum (if one
is necessary), you now have a set of construction documents
that reflects your dental equipment requirements
with 98-100 percent accuracy. Only if these requirements
are on paper will you be protected from “change orders”
during the construction phase of your project. This extra
effort from your dental equipment consultant and architect
is worth its weight in gold.
|