Perio Reports Vol. 23 No. 9 |
Perio Reports provides easy-to-read research summaries on topics of specific interest to clinicians.
Perio Reports research summaries will be included in each issue to keep you on the cutting edge
of dental hygiene science.
|
Dental Treatment and
Vascular Events
Treatment and control of periodontal disease might
reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease. Other research suggests
a transient risk associated with invasive dental procedures
and the likelihood of a heart attack or stroke in the
first few weeks following treatment. Low grade chronic
inflammation is linked to cardiovascular disease. Acute
inflammation after surgery or a bacterial infection is associated
with a short-term increased risk of changes in blood
vessels leading to stroke or heart attack.
Researchers at the Eastman Dental Institute in London,
England analyzed the United States Medicaid claims database
to determine if invasive dental treatment led to heart attack
or stroke immediately after treatment. A total of nearly 10
million patient records over a five-year period were analyzed
to find 20,000 who had been hospitalized for either stroke or
heart attack. Of these patients, 1,152 underwent invasive
dental procedures prior to hospitalization.
Invasive dental procedures included all treatment codes
related to periodontal therapy and tooth extractions, with
89 percent of these procedures relating to extractions.
No vascular event occurred on the same day as the dental
visit, but the majority happened within four weeks of
treatment. Although invasive dental treatment might be
linked to vascular events in the month after treatment, the
long-term benefit of treating dental disease far outweighs
this risk. These findings do provide evidence of the link
between acute inflammation and the risk of vascular events.
Clinical Implications: Within this targeted population of Medicaid patients, invasive dental treatment might present a transient risk for heart attack or stroke in the first four weeks following treatment, but this risk is outweighed by long-term benefits from dental treatment.
Minassian, C., D'Aluto, V., Hingorani, A., Smeeth, L.:
Invasive Dental Treatment and Risk for Vascular Events. Ann
Intern Med 153: 499-506, 2010. |
Perio Patients Seen in Emergency Rooms
Periodontal disease is best controlled with regular maintenance
visits and adequate daily oral hygiene. When regular
dental visits are not followed, serious problems occur and
patients seek treatment at hospital emergency rooms. Those
without dental insurance also seek care in hospital emergency
rooms. Data is collected each year from emergency rooms
across the U.S. and published in a Nationwide Emergency
Department Sample (NEDS).
Researchers at Harvard University in Boston, Massachusetts
analyzed data from 2006 NEDS to determine how
many visits were because of periodontal problems and if these
emergency visits led to hospitalization.
During 2006, there were 120,033,750 emergency room
visits with 85,039 of these visits being categorized with a primary
diagnosis of periodontal disease. More patients were
seen on weekend days than on weekdays. Some of these cases
also had other medical problems including diabetes, heart
disease, lung disease, liver disease, thyroid problems, alcohol
abuse or HIV. A total of 1,167 of these emergency room visits
required inpatient hospitalization.
The financial implications of these emergency room visits
were close to $33.3 million with an average charge per visit
of $456. For those who were also hospitalized, the charges
escalated to $15,248 per visit.
Inpatient hospitalization occurred more often for those
with multiple medical problems and for those with a primary
diagnosis of acute or aggressive periodontitis rather than
chronic periodontitis.
Clinical Implications: Prevention of periodontal disease
with effective daily oral hygiene and regular dental and
dental hygiene visits is important to treat and prevent
serious periodontal conditions that might otherwise lead
patients to seek treatment at a hospital emergency room.
Elangovan, S., Nalliah, R., Allareddy, V., Karimbux, N.,
Allareddy, V.: Outcomes in Patients Visiting Hospital Emergency
Departments in the United States Because of Periodontal
Conditions. J Perio 82: 809-819, 2011. |
Host Modulation Helps Smokers
Smoking is a serious risk factor for periodontal disease
and compromises clinical healing following therapy.
Smoking suppresses the body's immune response, triggers the
release of cytokines which destroy healthy connective tissue
and prevent these cells from organizing and healing. Despite
a great deal of research confirming the role of smoking
in the progression of periodontal disease,
treatment and maintenance are the same for
smokers and non-smokers. There are no wellestablished
protocols to follow when treating
periodontal patients who continue to smoke.
Researchers at the University of Alabama,
School of Dentistry in Birmingham, Alabama
reviewed the literature to determine if the use of
host modulation therapy in smokers would be beneficial
with both scaling and root planing and during maintenance
care.
They reviewed 31 abstracts on the subject and narrowed it
down to 13 full articles, of which nine were relevant to their
question. The two host modulation drugs tested were low-dose
doxycycline and low-dose flurbiprofen. Overwhelmingly, the
data demonstrated improved periodontal healing following
scaling and root planing when host modulation therapy was
provided for smokers. Differences were more pronounced in
moderate and deep pockets compared to shallow pockets.
When these low-dose drugs are given to smokers in conjunction
with treatment or maintenance, bacterial counts
are reduced for the most pathogenic species.
Since smoking causes an increase in inflammation,
providing a host modulation drug
that reduces the level of cytokines released
will enhance healing.
Clinical Implications: Based on the research,
it makes sense to offer a host modulation drug
to smokers being treated for periodontal disease
and smokers receiving periodontal maintenance.
Geisinger, M., Holmes, G., Geurs, N., Vassilopoulos, P., Reddy,
M.: Host Modulation for Smokers Undergoing Periodontal
Maintenance: A Review of Current Evidence. Clin Adv
Periodontics 1: 54-60, 2011. |
Rapid Recolonization After Treatment
Bacterial biofilm is the trigger which starts the periodontal
disease cascade. Researchers have identified hundreds of bacterial
species within biofilm and grouped them according to pathogenicity
by color groups. Red and orange are the most
pathogenic; green and yellow less so; and purple and blue the
least pathogenic.
Researchers at the Forsyth Institute in Boston, Massachusetts
wanted to know if there were differences in plaque recolonization
and species after instrumentation in both periodontally
healthy and diseased patients. A group of 38 patients participated
in the study; 17 had chronic periodontitis with at least
eight teeth probing over 4mm and the rest, considered
healthy, had less than 20 percent of sites with gingivitis, redness
or bleeding.
Supra and subgingival plaque samples were taken from 28
teeth in each individual at baseline. Subjects then received either
a prophylaxis or full-mouth scaling and root planing. Plaque
samples were taken immediately after treatment on all 28 teeth.
Samples were taken from seven teeth in randomly selected quadrants
on days one, two, four and seven.
Baseline bacterial counts were higher in periodontitis subjects
compared to healthy subjects. Supra- and subgingival
counts reached or exceeded baseline levels at day two.
In both groups, there were two spikes in repopulation of
subgingival plaque, between days one and two and between days
four and seven. This might be due to environmental changes in
the subgingival area favoring different species.
Clinical Implications: Skipping oral hygiene for just two days allows bacteria to rebound to baseline levels or higher. This is good information to share with patients.
Uzel, N., Teles, F., Telles, R., Song, Z., Torresyap, G, Socransky, S.,
Haffajee, A.: Microbial Shifts During Dental Biofilm Re-
Development in the Absence of Oral Hygiene in Periodontal Health
and Disease. J Clin Perio 38: 612-620, 2011. |
Listerine Used for Ultrasonic Lavage
The goal of non-surgical periodontal therapy is to reduce
probing depths and bleeding and return all pockets to
health. Providing scaling and root planing in chronic periodontitis
cases does not always return all pockets to
probing depths less than 5mm. Remaining pockets
present a risk for further disease.
Researchers at the University of Sao Paulo in
Brazil compared ultrasonic instrumentation using
Listerine Cool Mint as the lavage to an identical
tasting and colored placebo. A group of 64 patients
were treated with traditional scaling and root
planing using power and hand instruments in four
to six sessions each. Four weeks later, these
patients were again examined and all still had four
to 10 sites measuring 5mm or more. This was
baseline for the study.
Subjects received five minutes of ultrasonic scaling in each remaining diseased
site using the randomly assigned lavage, either Listerine or control rinse.
The Listerine and control rinse containers were identical, marked either Group
A or Group B. No one knew the group assignments until the six-month study
was completed. Periodontal exams were repeated at four, six and 24 weeks.
When comparing all data, no differences were seen between test and control
groups for probing depths, clinical attachment levels, recession or bleeding
on probing. A small difference was observed for pockets initially measuring
7mm or more. The Listerine group showed 0.65mm greater probing depth
reduction and 0.77mm greater gain in clinical attachment. Not reported were
reductions in the total number of sites 5mm or more.
Clinical Implications: For initially deep pockets, using Listerine Cool Mint in the ultrasonic scaler might enhance healing slightly.
Feng, H., Bernado, C., et al.: Subgingival Ultrasonic Instrumentation of Residual
Pockets Irrigated with Essential Oils: A Randomized Controlled Trial. J Clin Perio
38: 637-643, 2011. |
Pain Relief Patch for Perio Surgery Sites
Ketorolac (Toradol) is a non-sterioidal anti-inflammatory drug used to control pain
and inflammation. It is delivered by injections or in oral tablets often causing gastrointestinal
(GI) problems. To avoid GI problems, other delivery systems have been investigated,
including transdermal delivery, ophthalmic solutions and an oral rinse. The
newest delivery system is an intra-oral
patch made of two bioadhesive polymers:
hygroxypropyl methylcellulose and polyacrylic
acid.
Researchers at King Saud University
in Riyadh, Saudia Arabia tested the new
adhesive patch containing 30mg of
ketorolac. Test and placebo patches were
tested on free-gingival graft sites in 68
patients in a double-blind study. The test
group received the ketorolac patches
immediately after surgery and the control
group received the placebo patches. Pain
levels were recorded by patients using a
visual analog scale from zero to 10 with
mild pain equaling zero to four, moderate
pain equaling four to seven and severe
pain equaling seven or higher.
Pain scores immediately after surgery
were 7.7 for both groups. Test group
scores were 5.2 at one hour, 3.4 at two and
three hours, 2.0 at four hours and negligible
after that. Pain in the control group
was 7.8 at one hour and 5.63 at two
hours. At this point, control patches were
replaced with the ketorolac patches. One
hour later, pain scores dropped to 3.4,
then 2.5 at four hours, 1.3 at five hours
and negligible after that up to 48 hours.
Clinical
Implications: Oral pain relief patches might be available in the future for use after surgical procedures.
Hal-Hezaimi, K., Al-Askar, M., Selamhe,
Z., Fu, J., Alsarra, I., Wang, H.: Evaluation
of Novel Adhesive Film Containing
Ketorolac for Post-Surgery Pain Control: A
Safety and Efficacy Study. J Perio 82: 963-
968, 2011. |