
Every dentist from the first day of dental school has heard of the high rates of
suicide, alcoholism and divorce in the dental profession. Dentistry has held this
reputation for many decades. When one thinks of addiction, alcohol and drugs
are at the top of the list. There are also, behavioral addictions such as compulsive
gambling, sexual compulsivity, eating disorders, compulsive shopping and
problematic Internet use. Dentists and their family members can be affected by
one or more of these addictions.
Addiction is a complex primary, biogenetic, psychosocial, chronic progressive disease
that if left untreated could lead to death. The good news is addiction responds well
to adequate treatment. A recent definition of addiction is as follows, "Addiction coops
the brain's neuronal circuits necessary for insight, motivation and social behaviors. This
functional overlap results in addicted individuals making poor choices despite awareness
of the negative consequences; it explains why previously rewarding life situations
and the threat of judicial punishment cannot stop curtailing addictions."¹
Dentists are especially susceptible to addictions and emotional impairments due
to their stressful working environment and striving for perfection. Dentists are
trained to be both technicians and artists, performing exacting procedures in isolated
environments, determined to achieve the mythical "ideal restoration."
Dentists who are prone to addiction struggle with exaggerated fears, deficient interpersonal
skills, internalizing their patients' anxieties, a competitive nature and easy access to drugs. These burdensome circumstances can result in the feelings of
inadequacy or failure, and create a fertile ground for addiction and or psychological
disorders. This begins on the first day of dental school and carries
over following graduation. Some individuals deal with these stressors better
than others. Stated another way, some of us deal with life on life's terms better
than others.

The percentage of the dental profession affected by addiction is basically
the same as the general population; estimates range from 11 to 20 percent.
However, there are subtle differences specific for dentists with addictive diseases.
For instance, the drug of choice may be different in most cases, but the
disease of addiction is the same. Addiction tends to progress over time. At
first, addicted dentists can be a master at hiding their drug use from their
family, office staff, and of course patients. Family and office staff might begin
to make excuses for deteriorating behavior and performance. When excuses
begin, this enables the addictive disease to begin to spiral downward. The isolation
of a solo dental practice further contributes to this process. The dentist
with an addiction feels very isolated and alone. He or she feels that they
are the only one in the dental profession that are in the throws of addiction.
As addiction progresses, personal and professional lives deteriorate. Most
individuals with the addiction tend to blame others, events, circumstances – you name it – for their problems. The dentist with an addiction will be in
denial that he or she indeed has an addiction. For the most part, they are
incapable of asking for or receiving help. It has been reported that suicide was
actually the result of the end stage disease of addiction.
Often the denial is broken as a result of some sort of intervention. This
can come in the form of an investigation from a state dental board, a DUI,
some type of personal or professional crisis, or even a well-planned professional
intervention. The goal of an intervention is for the dentist involved to
have a multidisciplinary evaluation by professionals in addiction treatment
and hopefully follow through with the recommended treatment. This is
when the healing begins as the dentist begins his or her journey in recovery.
Discovering there are other dentists in recovery is very comforting and provides
tremendous support for those just beginning their journeys.
Most state dental associations have programs to assist dentists, dental
team members as well as family members dealing with addiction or wellbeing
issues. These programs have been in existence for many years and have
helped thousands of dentists restore their personal and professional lives.
There exists in dentistry, as well as other professions, something called,
"The Conspiracy of Silence." This involves knowing or strongly suspecting a
fellow dentist or even a patient of an addiction issue and taking no steps to
help this person. By saying nothing or doing nothing the individual with the addiction continues to suffer in desperation. Generally, we, (the dental profession)
keep silent by rationalizing, "It is none of my business," or, "I am not
my brother's or sister's keeper."
Most dentists and dental team members know a professional colleague or
patient who is indeed suffering from an addictive disease. The suffering colleague
might be in one's own geographic area or even a classmate in a different
part of the state or country. Indications that a professional colleague may
be having an addictive disease issue is not difficult to notice. Dentists need
to be diligent as well with their patient populations for those in active disease
as well as recovery.
It is fairly easy to familiarize yourself with knowledge of addictions. An
excellent source of information is a dentist who is in recovery. Most are very
helpful in sharing their stories of addiction and the journey in recovery. Our
patients who are in recovery are also great resources. Look on the Web site of
your State Dental Association to see if they have information concerning well
being or addiction issues. I have also provided you with a list of resources you
can contact.
If you are concerned about a professional colleague, pick up the phone
and call the Program Director of the Well-being Program in your particular
state. The information you provide is strictly confidential. Your phone call
may save your colleague's personal and professional life.
Briefly discussing addiction in the dental profession is comparable to a
writing exercise in Philosophy 101. The assignment: "Discuss the meaning
of life as it relates to the forces of good and evil, compare and contrast, give
two examples of each, and do this in 150 words or less." This is the first of
several articles specifically on the various aspects of addiction in dentistry I
aim to write for Dentaltown Magazine over the next year.
Reference
1. Volkow, N. D., Baler, R.D., Goldstein, R.Z., Neuron 69, Feb 24, 2011 p 599
|
William T, Kane, DDS, MBA, graduated from the University of Missouri – Kansas City
School of Dentistry in 1980. He maintains a general practice in rural Dexter, Missouri. In
addition to practicing dentistry, Dr. Kane's interest and passion have been in the area
of recovery and wellness. Since 1987, Dr. Kane has been the Chairman of the Dentist
Well – Being Committee for the Missouri Dental Association. Additionally, Dr. Kane
served as a member of the Dental Wellness Advisory Committee (DWAC) with the American Dental
Association. Dr. Kane is very familiar with issues facing patients with addictive diseases and has
published and presented on these topics. He also completed an MBA in 1992 from Southeast
Missouri State University. In the fall of 2010, Dr. Kane received his Fellowship in the American
College of Dentists. |
National and State Health
& Wellness Programs
ADA Dental Health and
Wellness Department
Web site: www.ada.org/4497.aspx
Contacts:
Alison M. Siwek, Manager
siweka@ada.org
312-440-2622
Mary Gilliam, senior project assistant
gilliamm@ada.org
312-440-7473
State Dental Associations
Colorado Dental Association Concerned Colorado Dentists
Web site:
http://www.cdaonline.org
Contact: Michael Ford
303-810-4475
Louisiana Dental Association Dental Well Being Advisory Committee
Web site: www.ladental.org/cms/content/view/181/41/
Contact: Jamie Manders, NODA
jamiemanders@yahoo.com
504-366-8193
Maryland State Dental Association
Dentist Well Being Committee
Web site: www.dentistwellbeing.com/
Contact: Robert White,
Clinical Coordinator
410-328-8549
Massachusetts Dental Association
Dentist Well Being (C-DAD)
Web site: www.cdad.org
Contact: Thomas Derosier, Chair
tderosier@aol.com
508-540-0303
Minnesota Dental Association
Dentist Wellness Program
Web site: www.mndental.org/dentist_home/member_services/wellness_program/
Contact: Sand Creek Group
800-632-7643
Mississippi Dental Association
Council of Supportive Services
Web site: www.msdental.org/aboutmda/councils
Contacts: Bruce Scarborough, Chair
601-446-8389
Montana Dental Association
Dentist Health and Wellness
Web site: www.mtdental.com
Contacts: Ingrid McLellan, Council Member
dr-ingrid@qwestoffice.net
406-443-5526
Nevada Dental Association
Northern Nevada Dentist Health and
Wellness Committee
Web site: www.nndental.org/default.php?p=Co
Contacts: Michael Day, Chairman
mday212735@aol.com
775-358-5265
New York State Dental Association
Chemical Dependency Committee
Contacts: Health Affairs
jdonnelly@nysdental.org
800-255-2100
North Dakota Dental Association
North Dakota Dept. of Health
Oral Health Program
Web site: www.ndhealth.gov/oralhealth
Contacts: Kimberlie Yineman, Director
kyineman@nd.gov
701-328-4930
Rhode Island Dental Association
Dentists Health
Web site: www.ridental.com/councils.cfm
Contacts: Robert Champagne
401-351-1110
Raymond George, Jr.
401-434-1127
Colegio de Cirujanos Dentistas de
Puerto Rico
Commission of Oral Health
Web site: www.ccdpr.org/portada/comisiones/26
Contacts: Arminda Rivera Mora, President
drariveramora@gmail.com
787-242-1187 |