Struggling Dental Practice Battles DSO Competition, Low-Income Demographics and Failing Marketing

Struggling Dental Practice Battles DSO Competition, Low-Income Demographics and Failing Marketing

A Townie need more new patients, nothing seems to be working


Thread summary (AI-generated): A solo dentist posted that he needs more new patients and nothing seems to be working. He invested in remodeling the office and ran targeted Google Ads, but the results were dismal as almost all inquiries were from Medicaid patients, whom he doesn’t accept, leading to zero return on investment. Around the same time, a new DSO moved into the area, spending heavily on SEO and online ads. Call volume plummeted from steady daily activity to just a few nonviable leads per day. The dentist now works only two days a week, handles front desk duties himself, and is debating whether to sell the practice, relocate or make strategic changes.

Dentists and marketers on Dentaltown responded with tough love and practical advice. Many pointed out that the demographics, low median household income, heavy Medicaid presence and dentist saturation, may simply be incompatible with a fee for service model. Several suggested going in network with more PPOs to get patient flow moving again or relocating entirely to a more affluent or underserved area. Others noted that while DSOs dominate advertising, they often alienate patients with overtreatment and poor experiences. These patients may be looking for a more honest, personal dentist, but only if the marketing communicates that clearly.

The thread emphasized that marketing alone won’t save a misaligned practice. The dentist had tried yard signs, discount emergency visits, Google ads and flyers, but without consistent branding or a clear value proposition, none worked. Several posters said the real problem might be internal: unclear messaging, weak phone conversion, lack of patient referrals and limited availability. Despite the dentist’s insistence that service is strong, many warned that 50 Google reviews won’t cut it in a competitive market and don’t necessarily reflect what’s happening inside the office.

Some advised acquiring charts from a retiring dentist in town to quickly add volume without deep discounting or expanding insurance participation. Others stressed reworking the brand: better website, more Google reviews, video testimonials, strategic social media, direct mail targeting higher income neighborhoods and offering financing framed around convenience rather than affordability.

Some dentists said they once felt similarly stuck but recovered by focusing inward, improving systems, and grinding through the hard phase. Others said they burned out trying to force success in areas that no longer had viable patient bases and wished they had moved sooner.


Join the Conversation!


Sponsors
Townie Perks
Townie® Poll
Who or what do you turn to for most financial advice regarding your practice?
  
Sally Gross, Member Services Specialist
Phone: +1-480-445-9710
Email: sally@farranmedia.com
©2025 Dentaltown, a division of Farran Media • All Rights Reserved
9633 S. 48th Street Suite 200 • Phoenix, AZ 85044 • Phone:+1-480-598-0001 • Fax:+1-480-598-3450