by Trisha E. O'Hehir, RDH, MS
Dental caries remains a significant problem responsible for pain, suffering, disfigured smiles,
impaired function, lost hours of school and work, and of course, considerable expense, worldwide.
Today, our understanding of the complex caries process has led to earlier diagnosis, before cavitation
occurs. Early diagnosis of demineralization opens up opportunities for remineralizaton of
tooth surfaces, avoiding the need to amputate part of a tooth in order to place a restoration.
|
With this new understanding of demineralization and remineralization, diagnosis doesn't wait
for the patient to report pain and is no longer a simple yes-no decision of whether the tooth surface
is cavitated. Diagnosis today involves measuring early, subclinical caries activity in the enamel
and dentin and new technology is making that task easier and more objective.
The Caries Process
cay beginning on the inside of the tooth and working their
way out. That idea has more truth to it than we realize. There are
no tooth worms, but the acid-produced demineralization of the
enamel does in fact begin below the outer enamel surface. Acid
from several sources penetrates the enamel and begins the demineralization
process. This is a dynamic process that moves from
demineralization to remineralization and back. As long as there
is sufficient saliva to remineralize and the acid load can be balanced,
no break in the enamel will occur. When the acid levels
overwhelm the salivary remineralization, the demineralization
process continues to undermine the enamel surface, eventually
leading to a break or cavitation in the enamel surface. This allows
acid and acid-producing bacteria access to deeper areas and protection
from routine daily cleaning and salivary neutralization.
Caries Detection
Diagnosis classifications D1-D4 differentiate carious lesions
based on progression. D1 are clinically detectable enamel lesions
with intact enamel, D2 are cavitated lesions within the enamel,
D3 are both cavitated and non-cavitated lesions into the dentin
and D4 are lesions into the pulp. Carious lesions pass through
each of these stages, from subclinical demineralization to lesions
into the pulp, if they go that far.
Traditional caries lesion detection uses radiographs, a sharp
explorer, light and unwaxed dental floss. Radiographs show
lesions only after they have progressed at least 30 percent into
the enamel. A sharp explorer is now considered obsolete and
harmful rather than helpful, as it can break through softened,
demineralized enamel, causing cavitation and eliminating the
option of remineralization. Even narrow diameter explorers cannot
reach the base of deep pits or fissures to detect decay. Air,
light and magnification are more effective for evaluating enamel
surfaces, specifically occlusal surfaces. Researchers suggest that
sharp explorers no longer be used to detect stickiness on occlusal
surfaces. Although sharp explorers are still widely used this way,
they can actually create cavitation before it occurs, moving the
lesion to a level that can no longer benefit from remineralization
therapy. Research does not support the use of sharp explorers
and because of this, some dental schools now teach that it is
unethical to use a sharp explorer to look for initial lesions in
occlusal pits and fissures.
Diagnosis classification D1-D4 do not identify subclinical
lesions that are in a dynamic state of progression and regression,
demineralization and remineralization. Technology now provides
many options for detecting the early demineralization of
enamel and determining how far lesions have progressed. When
used after remineralization therapy, these technologies provide
valuable information on the success of those efforts.
Caries Diagnostic Systems
Digital Radiography
Visual inspection of film radiographs is no longer the most
effective means of diagnosing early caries. In a study published
in The Journal of the American Dental Association (JADA) by Dr.
S. White showed the depth of caries was misdiagnosed up to 40
percent of the time and healthy teeth were misdiagnosed as having
caries 20 percent of the time when looking at film radiographs.
Other studies showed no difference between film and
digital when visually diagnosing caries. The advantage of digital
is the ability to enlarge the image and change contrast for better
visualization. Now there is a software program available as an
optional component of the Kodak RVG system that analyzes
tooth density and demineralization patterns. Logicon Caries
Detector Software uses a database of histologically validated
caries cases to compare images for diagnosis. Graphics and visual
aids provide a Tooth Density Variation Chart and a Lesion
Probability Chart.
Light Illumination
Transillumination enhances vision by passing intense incandescent
yellow-to-white light through tooth surfaces. Because
healthy tooth enamel has a light transmission index greater than
decay or calculus, differences will be seen visually. These products
provide greater light than overhead or headlamps for caries
diagnosis. Many devices can transilluminate a tooth: standard
light for ear, nose and throat examinations, composite curing
lights, small light probes used in electronics that look like tiny
flashlights and the fiber optics built into handpieces.
Microlux Transilluminator Diagnostic System from
AdDent, Incorporated, illuminates tooth structure to detect
changes in enamel. Aiming light through the teeth from facial to
lingual and viewing the surface with a mouth mirror shows
defects in the enamel as dark shadows.
Audible Signal Plus and Light
DIAGNOdent and the DIAGNOdent Pen from KaVo use
laser fluorescence technology for detecting
occlusal caries. A baseline reading is
taken from each patient just prior to
evaluating surfaces for decay. Both an
audible signal and digital number
measure laser-reflected light. Quantified
laser-reflected light can be used to detect
a carious lesion. The DIAGNOdent
quantifies the lesion based on the following
reading:
• 0-10 healthy
• 10-20 early caries in the outer enamel
• 20-30 caries extending into the inner enamel
• 30+ dentinal caries
The Midwest Caries I.D. utilizes LED light and contains
three separate fiber-optic fibers. One fiber emits green light, one
emits red and the third is the receiving fiber. The light passes
through the enamel rods and if the surface is healthy, the LED
light is absorbed into the tooth and the green light remains on.
When the enamel is demineralized or caries is present, the LED
light will be reflected, refracted or scattered. The receiving fiber
captures this light as red. The message to the clinician is either
the green light, indicating healthy tooth structure or red, indicating
demineralization or caries. Color indicators are accompanied
by an audible tone.
The level of involvement is indicated by the rate of pulsed
light. A rapid, medium or slow pulse corresponds to high,
medium or slight decalcification. Interproximal caries can be
detected by scanning the mesial or distal marginal ridges.
Visual Imaging Diagnostics
Spectra Caries Detection Aid from Air Techniques, Inc.,
connects to your computer through the USB port. It uses light-induced
fluorescence produced by LEDs that project high energy
violet blue light. Images of sound enamel appear green.
Light of this wavelength stimulates metabolites of cariogenic
bacteria to appear as red.
Soprolife from Acteon Imaging is an intraoral camera and
caries-detection device in one. It combines Sopro video imaging
and light-induced fluorescence to provide images magnified 30-
to 100-times actual size. Soprolife offers two views, one using blue
light and the other using white light. Blue lights allow observation
of the tooth structure and white lights show the periodontium.
CarieScan Pro from 3D Diagnostic Imaging in the U.K. is
the first to use electrical Impedance Spectroscopy Technology.
Using six blue LED lights, the CarieScan Pro produces a computer
image much like Doppler radar used for weather reporting.
The device is small, lightweight, battery-operated, automatically
calibrated and Bluetooth-enabled to capture readings wirelessly.
A low-amplitude microamp current passes through the tooth
structure penetrating enamel, dentin and
pulp to provide mineral density changes.
Electrical impedance is measured and
compared to a map of reference teeth collected
from six years of research at universities
in Scotland. Probability of disease is
given with scores from 0 to 100 and a
colored inDECAYtor. The impedance of
a healthy tooth structure is greater than
demineralized tooth structure, including
dentin. Readings over time monitor disease
progression and the effectiveness of remineralization therapy.
Future Products
Canary Dental Caries Detection System by Quantum
Dental Technologies, a Canadian company uses Photothermal
Radiometry and Modulated Luminescence (FDPTR
and LUM) or a low-power, pulsating laser light that
can provide information to a depth of 5mm. As the laser
light is absorbed by the tooth, two phenomena are observed.
First, the laser light is converted into luminescence and secondly,
heat of less than one degree Celsius is released, which
does not harm the tooth. Demineralization is measured by
combining data on the reflected heat and the reflected light.
This information is displayed on a touch screen monitor in
an Odontogram showing both Canary numbers and color
codes depicting the level of demineralization or remineralization.
The higher the Canary numbers, the greater the level
of demineralization. The Canary System comes from Canada
and should be available in the United States before the end
of 2011.
Conclusion
These new caries detection technologies provide cutting
edge tools for dentists and hygienists that provide non-invasive
methods for determining the level of health and disease in teeth.
The dental industry is changing to encompass a more preventive
model rather than the more traditional repair or amputation
model. New detection methods like these and those soon to be
introduced to the dental market help pave the way for clinicians
to intervene earlier and thus save natural tooth structure. Early
intervention for prevention will allow many to maintain healthy
tooth structure for a lifetime rather than following a lifelong
path of tooth repair. |