An interview on ozone research with Professor Edward Lynch, MA, BDentSc, PhD
by Trisha O’Hehir, RDH, BS, Hygienetown Editorial Director
The body of ozone research has grown over the past decade
to more than 100 published research studies. This new technology
was used first in dental practices in the UK and Europe, and
has been slow to gain recognition and prominence in the United
States. It was first thought that ozone needed FDA approval to
be used in the United States, but it has been grandfathered in
because ozone was used in the medical and dental fields before
the 1906 Pure Food and Drug Act.
Ozone is blue, has a strong odor and contains three oxygen
atoms
(O3) and is primarily found in the earth’s upper atmosphere
from about 10 km out to 50 km – the stratosphere. It is
thinnest at the equator and thicker toward the poles. This
ozone layer absorbs some of the sun’s harmful ultraviolet rays,
protecting us from them. The term “ozone” comes from the
ancient Greeks who noticed the strong smell after electrical
storms and the good fishing that followed. Native Americans
made the same connection and the custom of fishing after an
electrical storm remains a custom today. Ozone is considered
the agent of choice for the disinfection of public water supplies
as it kills bacteria by rupturing cell membranes within two seconds.
Medical uses for ozone date back to the mid 1800s when
it was first used for purifying blood. Today it’s used for the
management of circulatory disorders, viral diseases and cancer.
Ozone used in dentistry penetrates tooth structures to eradicate
bacteria and enhance remineralization.
The man behind most of the research is Professor Edward
Lynch, of Warwick University in England. I’ve followed his
research and asked him many questions on this subject over the
past decade. Ozone therapy is already an integral part of both
prevention and dental therapy carried out by more than
100,000 dental care professionals worldwide.
Why hasn’t ozone therapy been more readily
accepted in the US?
Professor Edward Lynch: The generally perceived wisdom
has always been that dental caries is an infective process and the
only real treatment option was the cutting away, or amputation, of
all diseased tissue and its replacement with some form of restorative
material. This is the teaching that most dental students still
receive at dental schools around the world today, and is practiced
like a religion by the majority of dentists worldwide. Once entry
into this religion is gained, the individual is condemned to a cycle
of restorative care that becomes more expensive and complex as it
fails and has to be replaced. Some individuals may attain a state
of oral health that sees them achieve stability for many years, but
the vast majority will continue within this cycle of restorative
destruction and replacement.
In the past the restorative philosophy was
“extension for prevention,” cutting away healthy
tooth structure. Has that philosophy changed?
Lynch: There has been a move toward cutting smaller preparations,
toward an approach of minimally invasive dentistry,
with the associated benefits to both the clinician and patient.
Many techniques, however, still involve the physical removal of
tissue before the final restoration is placed. Ozone use fits perfectly
into this philosophy as it allows up to 1mm of caries to be
left on the cavity floor prior to ozone treatment and restoration.
What is the ideal treatment solution?
Lynch: The ideal treatment solution is the simple removal of
the cause of the disease process with no associated loss of sound
tissue and no associated physical discomfort for the patient. This
means earlier intervention; before cavitation of the lesion with
recent advances in the field of ozone treatment, this is now possible.
For the first time, the dentist can break the ongoing circle of
restorative dentistry, as it would appear placement of the initial
restoration is no longer always necessary. Once a filling is placed,
it will require eventual replacement and subsequent re-treatment.
Ideal treatment is preventing the first restoration. Ozone of course
should be combined with all our other preventive regimens.

When was ozone first used for dental care?
Lynch: The first record of ozone use in dental care was by a
Swiss dentist, Dr. E.A. Fisch, who used ozone in dentistry before
1932, and introduced it to the German surgeon Dr. Erwin Payr,
who used it from that time. However, ozone disappeared from
usage in dental care until 2000 when the first scientific studies
were published.
What did studies show?
Lynch: These studies showed that acids produced by bacteria
were oxidized to less acidic products by the ozone treatment,
for example pyruvic acid is oxidised by ozone into acetate and
carbon dioxide. They also proved the excellent antimicrobial
effectiveness of ozone. These antimicrobial effects and oxidative
by-products adjusted the lesion pH to being more alkaline, so
allowing a net gain of minerals by the lesion. This remineralization
process is the fundamental by-product of ozone treatment
that leads to predictable mineral uptake by a treated surface. By
eliminating the ecological niche and acid niche environment, the
lesion can undergo a natural mineral uptake, so healing itself.
Please explain the bacterial niche concept and
how ozone works in this concept.
Lynch: According to “The Niche Environment Theory,”
a “microbial niche” is established within a carious lesion.
Microorganisms are far from the “simple bugs” having survived
for billions of years, where humans have but a minute time
frame of existence in comparison. The dental profession should
not be surprised to learn that bacteria set up complex interactions
with other bugs, talk to neighboring colonies when times
are good, and call for help from others when their host attempts
to change their environment. Protein coatings, plaque and
debris are known to protect these colonies by reducing the effect
of pharmaceutical agents designed to eliminate these microbial
colonies. Ozone has the effect, through its powerful oxidizing
properties, of not only removing the protein protection and
being bactericidal, but also oxidizing the biomolecules that
allow the niche to survive and expand. This has a severely disruptive
effect on the bacterial population in the carious lesion
and obliterates the cariogenic bacteria and their ecological niche,
thereby swinging the equilibrium in favor of remineralization. No more acid can be produced within the lesion when the acid-producing
microorganisms are eliminated or severely reduced.
After ozone therapy, the lesion will become populated with
more normal mouth commensals, which do not produce significant
acid.
Many studies have shown that caries reversal is
possible, but how do you predict which lesions
will, and which will not, reverse.
Lynch: Ozone treatment, combined with added oral hygiene
products that increase the oral fluid concentration of bio-available
minerals, makes this remineralization process predictable.
New technology also provides objective rather than subjective
diagnosis of the demineralizaton process. The more shallow the
carious lesion the more predictable the remineralization will be.
Published studies have shown a caries reversal rate of from
84 percent to 99 percent, depending on which protocol is followed.
Where only one variable is used, for example ozone or
no-ozone, the reversal range is from 84 percent to 92 percent.
Compare this to periodic ozone treatment in combination with
oral hygiene instruction, strict usage of remineralization products,
and including only shallow lesions, and reversal rates of up
to 100 percent are achieved. Following this treatment protocol
provides outcomes that are more predictable.
How will diagnosis of caries lesions change with
this more preventive approach?
Lynch: Clinicians have to completely reassess their diagnostic
and detection criteria when applied to dental caries.
The International Caries Detection and Assessment System
(ICDAS) provides a new visual assessment tool with excellent
criteria. The dental explorer is no longer of any significant use
for caries detection and hence examination is based on the use
of a digital intraoral camera combined with selective use of the
DIAGNOdent, which has been extensively tested against the
Electric Caries Monitor (Lode, Belgium) and against conventional
diagnostic criteria. Looking for holes with an explorer is a
concept that cannot be part of modern dental care. The detection
of demineralization within the enamel layer is of paramount
importance, before the carious process has an
opportunity to penetrate into the dentin below. Measuring the
results of ozone therapy show immediate and lasting results,
based on changes in DIAGNOdent reading.*
Most people, myself included, don’t enjoy having
local anesthesia and drilling on our teeth. How
do your patients react to ozone treatment?
Lynch: Patients are delighted after treatment and are particularly
motivated toward oral hygiene and dietary control and fluoride
use when they realize that in improving and concentrating
on these areas they can effectively avoid the local anesthesia/drill
approach for shallow lesions. Of course, there are still situations
where treatment will follow more classical lines. However, these
instances are becoming increasingly rare. Treatment acceptance
of my patients and of those reported in the research is usually
100 percent. Patients, especially parents, prefer preventing the
need for any anesthesia and drilling for their children.
Is ozone used for more than remineralization?
Lynch: A wide variety of carious lesions can be treated with
no need for local anesthesia, no need for drilling, and in a very
short appointment, totally painless and totally atraumatic.
Where caries has penetrated into the deeper dentinal tissue,
ozone still has an important role to play. In these cases, the loose
debris is first removed to the leathery subsurface, ozone is
applied, and then remineralizing solutions and glass ionomers
can be applied. Carious tissue still has to be removed whether by
use of the handpiece, air abrasion, or with hand instruments
(ART) when used in conjunction with caries removing liquids
and gels (e.g. Carisolv). Ozone treatment of dental caries
removes the requirement for physical removal of diseased tissue
as the dental profession is now promoting remineralization and
not amputation of carious dentin.
Can ozone be used for root surface caries?
Lynch: Yes, ozone is clinically effective in the management
of root carious lesions. These lesions often present in the elderly
who may have associated medical problems, which complicate
their dental management. Using ozone therapy, such lesions are
easily treated. The portability of ozone units facilitates its use in
the domiciliary setting and treatment is also simplified because
the clinician does not need to carry a range of restorative
materials on such visits. Dentists using ozone units for caries
management, encourage their patients to regularly use a fluoride-
containing mouthwash, that will enhance the efficacy of
ozone by promoting remineralization and to reduce the frequency
of consumption of fermentable carbohydrates. Dr Julian
Holmes has published a double blind randomized controlled
clinical trial proving the reversal of shallow root carious lesions
using the HealOzone.
Is ozone used with fissure sealants?
Lynch: Ozone should be used prior to the placement of
every fissure sealant.
How are carious lesions treated in deciduous
teeth with ozone?
Lynch: Treatment is simple, fast (the average ozone time for
practitioners using ozone is 30 seconds) and can involve little
preparatory work. The loose debris is first cleaned away, until a leathery base is reached. This can be done with air abrasion or
hand instruments. Ozone is applied, the lesion wetted with a
remineralizing wash and then a glass ionomer can be placed.
Ozone treatment eliminates the bacteria and the glass ionomer
will supply long-term fluoride and mineral release, as well as
preventing ingress of food debris and re-establishment of the
acid-niche environment.
What ozone delivery systems are available
to clinicians?
Lynch: Two systems have been proven safe for dental use,
the HealOzone for treating tooth surfaces and reversing caries
and the TherOzone for treating water. The HealOzone system
produces ozone-oxidizing gas filtered through a dental handpiece
fitted with a special silicone cup to direct and control the
ozone gas safely to the tooth surface and back into the system.
Many dental offices use TherOzone treated water to control
microbial growth in unit waterlines, instead of regular water in
power scalers for scaling and root planing, and as the final irrigant
during root canal therapy.** Teeth may be whitened using
ozone gas or ozonated water combined with hydrogen peroxide,
due to its strong oxidizing properties.
A new unit, the CMU3 by Lime Technologies, allows a free
flow of ozone without a seal. Instead of returning back into the
unit and being converted to oxygen, the ozone is released into
the air around the application tip and is captured using high volume
evacuation. The risk with this delivery system is not removing
all the ozone or removing ozone before it has had sufficient
treatment time on the tooth surface.
The newest products available are ozonated oils and creams that
can be used topically, delivered subgingivally or delivered in a full-mouth
tray system. Grey Cell Enterprises in South Africa manufactures
organic ozonated oils and creams, also available in the USA.
Thank you Professor Lynch. It’s clear that ozone
therapy provides an exciting treatment modality
with considerable benefits for dental patients of
all ages. This treatment is simple and completely
safe. As a dental hygienist focused on prevention
of dental disease, ozone is sure to become
an important tool in this endeavor.
*Lynch, E. Evidence-based caries reversal using ozone. J Esthet Restor Dent. 2008;20(4):218-22.
**Lynch, E. Evidenced-based efficacy of ozone for root canal irrigation. J Esthet Restor Dent.
2008;20(5):287-93 |