Edsger Dijkstra said, “Simplicity is prerequisite for reliability.” There is much wisdom in this
quote from Professor Dijkstra. We begin with the acknowledgment that creating a denture in the traditional
method is not a simple process. We take for granted the incredible ability of the human brain
to recognize an aesthetically pleasing arch form while at the same time providing the hand-eye coordination
required to place teeth and create a functional occlusion.
So where is the simple part in producing a reliable digital denture? We would contend that
simplicity in digital denture production would never be achieved by trying to mimic a technician’s
actions – by forcing her/him to use an electronic device, for example – to place teeth one-by-one
in a virtual arch. True simplicity can only be achieved by understanding the desired results and the
fundamental dental principles necessary to achieve a quality denture. To
make this happen in the digital world, we have to recognize the limitations
of computers. To ensure a quality end-product we must also understand
materials and their properties, measurement devices and production
equipment. In engineering, this practice is called the boil down, and in
dentures this is called AvaDent.
In this article we will address the four important constituents of an
AvaDent: record taking, digital design, fabrication and validation.
There is a familiar phrase in computer engineering, “Garbage In,
Garbage Out.” Correspondingly, high-quality clinical records must
come “in” before a high-quality denture can go “out.” It is important
to note that in the AvaDent process we maintain 100 percent of the
clinical concepts needed for the ideal outcome; no shortcuts are taken.
To ensure successful record-taking, we have improved familiar dental
procedures, e.g., introducing form-fitting thermoplastic trays for
impression taking and providing easy-to-use precision tools such as the
Anatomical Measurement Device (AMD). The AMD provides a record
of VDO, midline, incisal edge, cervical margin and the aesthetic plane
of occlusion, all of which become part of the prescription. The AMD
also confirms CR by utilizing a built-in gothic tracing option. By coupling
hands-on training seminars with improved record-taking and
simplified, well-engineered tools, we reliably create AvaDents in a two appointment
process.
Materials are equally important for AvaDent. One well-known deficiency
in the traditional denture-base investment process is shrinkage
caused by conventional laboratory techniques. Shrinkage causes the denture to fit poorly, which results in discomfort and dysfunction. AvaDent denture bases are produced
by machining a pre-formed disk of acrylic material, which is formed by injection under high pressure
(50 times the pressure of other investment procedures). Since the
AvaDent is produced from an already-cured material, there is no shrinkage,
resulting in a better patient fit. An additional benefit of the high-pressure
cure is that the material becomes much more hydrophobic, which
leads to a more bio-hygienic denture. Here again, simplicity is achieved
through application of engineering principles.
The digital design phase for AvaDent begins when the impressions and
AMD (Fig. 1) arrive at the AvaDent laboratory. Here, the impressions and
AMD are digitized by use of light-scanning technology. No stone is ever
poured in the AvaDent process.
At this point, we transit from the physical world into the virtual world.
We now have virtual models (Figs. 2 & 3) of the patient’s anatomy,
including ridge shape, buccal reflection, frena and the natural rugae. The
creation of a digitized anatomy was a complicated problem to solve, but
now that we have solved it, here too we have attained simplicity.
At this point, the AvaDent software automatically locates ridges
(Fig. 4), which can be adjusted if necessary by a trained technician.
Next, buccal reflections are automatically found, frena are added, and
the digital model is trimmed (Fig. 5). Such automation greatly speeds
up the AvaDent design.
The upper and lower jaw impressions are now registered to the AMD,
yielding a complete representation of the mouth anatomy (Fig. 6).
AvaDent algorithms ensure that hot spots and impression anomalies are
mitigated. Again, an elegant engineering solution behind the scenes
results in a reliable outcome for the doctor and the patient.
Using well-established dental principles, tooth setting in the AvaDent
process has been simplified via digital design. Upper and lower tooth-setting
arches are based on a blend of information contained in the upper
and lower ridges, respectively (Fig. 7). Published and internal research
show that an arch function based on two fixed parameters from the prescription
(overjet and tooth size) and four adjustable parameters (posterior
width, anterior squareness, posterior curvature and anti-symmetry) is
sufficient to define complete upper and lower denture arches. Aesthetics
tend to dominate the arch shapes in the anterior region while function
dominates the posterior region. A real-time presentation of upper and
lower teeth, preset on the arches, allows the technician to quickly make
adjustments of the teeth for both aesthetics and function.
Once the teeth are preset, the next step is to occlude them; this is
part of the “magic” of AvaDent technology. Prior to AvaDent, in the
best-case scenario, a technician still had to set teeth manually – in software
– using a mouse, keyboard, space-ball or other electronic device.
Even if the software were sophisticated and did not allow the individual
teeth to interpenetrate, the mere act of getting any two teeth in the
proper position – let alone 28 – was at worst, incredibly frustrating, and
at best, very time consuming.
Enter AvaDent. When you consider that we have up to 28 teeth with
six degrees of freedom per tooth (three translations and three rotations)
with several state variables and forces for thousands of locations at any
point in time… it is a good thing computers can do the calculations fast.
We’ve boiled the problem down to a few simple requirements:
- Teeth must remain on a specified arch.
- Teeth can move but are constrained by the basic shape of the arch.
- Teeth cannot interpenetrate, either with their mesial-distal neighbors
or with their antagonists.
- Teeth must remain on or within a specified distance of the occlusal surface.
There are a few more requirements depending on which occlusal scheme
is chosen.
We solve the occlusion problem by uniquely blending a number of
computational solution techniques borrowed from finite element methods,
rigid body and contact mechanics and graph theory. While none of these
techniques is inherently simple, we have removed the onus of tooth placement
from the technician and placed it carefully into algorithms that will
rigorously achieve a proper occlusion. The result is a fully occluded digital
model (Fig. 8), true to the dental prescription.
The final digital step in creating an AvaDent is the denture base creation.
Again we let simplicity be our guide. We start with what is required:
realistic gingivae, minimum base thickness and properly sized sockets to
receive the mould teeth. We augment this with what is desired: addition of
the natural rugae to the upper, amount of root eminence, an optional postdam
with selectable shape and size, and selectable thickness for the buccal
margin and palate. Figure 9 shows a re-creation of the natural rugae on the
lingual side of the upper denture.
Once the AvaDent upper and lower are designed, they are translated to
machine code so that the denture bases can be fabricated from the preformed
acrylic disk. The prescribed teeth are subsequently bonded into the
precision-machined sockets. Each AvaDent denture is then polished,
inspected, cleaned and prepared for shipping. The inspection step compares
the as-fabricated denture with the digital design to ensure that the
finished AvaDent is of the highest quality.
At every step in the AvaDent process, a digital record is created and
stored in a database. What this means is that in the event an AvaDent is lost
or accidentally broken, we can quickly and easily produce another to its
original clinical specification. By letting simplicity be our guide, we have
created a digital denture that is exactly what the doctor ordered. This
changes dentures forever!
|