Kissability
by Trisha E. O’Hehir, RDH, BS
& Sushma Nachnani, PhD
It’s hard to miss all the research and press coverage lately promoting the perio-systemic link. Headlines like “Floss or Die” make a strong case for cleaning between the teeth to prevent heart disease and add years to your life. If people truly desired to prevent heart disease, sales of cheeseburgers and ice cream and the ever-burgeoning weight of the American public would be in decline. It’s not happening. When it comes to motivating people to comply with effective oral hygiene procedures, “kissability” trumps heart disease. Just look at the dental products aisles of stores in your neighborhood. The number of products promising fresh breath far outnumber the choices for dental floss!
Everyone experiences oral malodor or bad breath sometime during the day. It’s often transient, due to overnight bacterial accumulation, eating odor producing foods or xerostomia. However, reports suggest that 40 percent of the population suffers from chronic bad breath and half of this group experiences severe problems and embarrassment due to bad breath.
Kissability, or fresh breath, is desirable at all ages (except perhaps among 10- to-12-year-old boys). It’s important as we go through life, on professional and social levels, where people find themselves close enough to smell each other’s breath. Even our elders living in nursing homes want fresh breath as much as teenagers. Talking comfortably with others requires fresh breath. Those with bad breath, either young or old, are shunned by others and left out of social gatherings. Dental professionals are the experts perfectly positioned to help those with bad breath. Adding a fresh breath program to your practice will provide a needed service. Helping people become kissable provides a double effect. First is fresh breath and second is reducing, controlling and preventing caries and periodontal disease. Patients are not all motivated by avoiding dental disease or heart disease, but most people do want to be kissable!
Bad Breath Facts
Breath contains more than nitrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide
and water vapor. In 1971 Linus Pauling reported measuring 250
substances in exhaled air. Some of these substances the human
nose can smell, others it can’t. Modern technology has now
measured 1,000 unique substances in expelled air using mass
spectrometry (MS) and gas chromatography.
Bad breath falls into three broad categories: intraoral, extraoral
and imaginary. Most bad breath (90 percent) is intraoral,
stemming from oral bacteria breaking down proteins in food
debris, blood or epithelial cells and releasing hydrogen sulfide
gases in the mouth. Scrupulous oral hygiene including cleaning
between the teeth, and tongue cleaning will eliminate most
intraoral cases of bad breath. There is a link between periodontal
disease and bad breath, but some people have no signs of
periodontal disease and still suffer from bad breath. In these
cases, the cause might still be intraoral bacteria, especially accumulations
found on the dorsum of the tongue. Another contributing
factor is dehydration and xerostomia which reduce
salivary flow and therefore the protective washing and neutralizing
benefits that naturally control oral odors. Talking for long
periods will dry the mouth and increase oral malodor.
Approximately 10 percent of bad breath is extraoral. This
type of bad breath is due to infections or conditions in other
parts of the body other than the mouth. Some examples are gastroesophageal
reflux, chronic nasal, sinus and throat infections,
medications, liver and kidney diseases, various carcinomas,
chemotherapy, hormonal changes, eating disorders, dieting,
exercise, and even stress. Infections in areas other than the
mouth can release sulphur compounds into the blood stream
and these compounds are then released in expelled air through
the lungs.
Imaginary bad breath is a psychological condition called
halitophobia. These people, halitophobics, are convinced
they have bad breath, despite all evidence to the contrary
from clinicians and friends. They continue to seek treatment
for bad breath, never believing clinicians who assure them
they have fresh breath. These patients need reassurance from
clinicians in order to build trust and eventually overcome
their phobia. When all clinical treatment is complete, and the
patient insists he or she still has bad breath, referral to a counselor
might be indicated.
Precursor and Result of
Periodontal Disease
Foul smelling gases are released when the amino acids of
proteins are broken down, either through putrefaction of
foods or blood. The bad breath associated with periodontal
disease is due to the death and decomposition of epithelial
cells within periodontal pockets. In health, the turnover rate
of junctional epithelial cells is every two to four days. The rate
increases eight-fold with periodontitis, which means cells die
and give off volatile sulphur compounds every six hours. This
is the smell that can be detected in the bad breath of those
with periodontitis. You’ve probably diagnosed periodontal
disease while standing in a crowd or waiting in line at the
bank or grocery store.
Volatile sulphur compounds in the mouth have been
shown to enhance the permeability of the junctional epithelial
cells, thus allowing lipopolysaccharide toxins from the
bacteria to penetrate through the attachment and into the
underlying connective tissue, triggering the inflammatory
response causing periodontal destruction. With these two
examples of oral malodor, it is apparent that bad breath is
both the result of periodontal disease and a precursor to the
onset of periodontitis.
Measuring Bad Breath
It’s very difficult to smell your own breath. The common
practice of breathing into a cupped hand and then smelling
is not accurate. Instead, ask a spouse or close friend to tell
you if you have bad breath. To test your own breath, you can
lick the inside of your wrist with the back of your tongue.
Let it dry for 10 seconds and then smell it. That might give
you an idea how your breath smells, but there are several
more scientific ways to measure breath odor. The Halimeter
is a portable sulphide monitor which calculates the level of
volatile gasses produced by oral bacteria. OraChroma is a
portable, digital gas chromotograph. The gold standard is
still organolyptic testing, or one person sniffing another’s
breath. People who are organoleptic breath testers are trained
to distinguish between different levels of odor and types
of odors. New machines designed to measure substances in
expelled air are compared to organoleptic measurements to
establish their validity.
Due to hit the market by year’s end is a pocket-size salivary
test called “Okay to Kiss.” Research by Professor Mel
Rosenberg at Tel Aviv University has identified a symbiotic
relationship between gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria
that links to bad breath. It seems the way gram-positive
bacteria process glycoproteins leaves a sugar molecule that’s
easy for gram-negative bacteria to digest. Until now, most of
the focus has been on the gram-negative bugs, when in fact,
early detection of gram-positive bacteria might be the best
indicator of bad breath. Spitting into a little spoon holding
the reagent is not exactly romantic, so the research team is
working on a less conspicuous way to conduct the test. This
test might even have a place in the dental office to check oral
hygiene. If the bugs are there and active, the oral hygiene is
lacking. Professor Rosenberg’s saliva research is showing
promise for the diagnosis of lung cancer, asthma and ulcers.
Also, be sure to keep an eye out for new consumer “quickchecks”
for detection of bad breath causing compounds from
QuantRx Biomedical and ALT BioScience later this year or
early 2010.
Treatment
The primary treatment for 90 percent of those with bad
breath is effective oral hygiene, including tongue cleaning.
Bad breath is eliminated by reducing the bacterial load in
the mouth, killing bacteria, neutralizing the volatile sulphur
compounds, eating less fats, eating more frequently and
drinking more water. The bacterial load can easily be
reduced with good oral hygiene, both brushing and cleaning
between the teeth. Tongue cleaning is particularly valuable
when the back of the tongue is cleaned with either a tongue
cleaner or toothbrush. Bacterial load can also be reduced
considerably by ingesting xylitol five times daily. Xylitol can
be taken in the form of chewing gum and candies as well as
toothpaste, mouthrinse, dry mouth spray or tooth gel and
can potentially reduce the bacterial load by 50 percent.
Xylitol nasal spray or xylitol in a Neti pot will flush the
mucus from the nasal passages, eliminating another protein
source for bacteria.
Many fresh breath products simply mask the odor for a
short time and do not deal with the primary cause of the
odor: oral bacteria breaking down proteins and in the process
releasing foul smelling compounds. Mouthrinses have been
around for many centuries and have been concocted of a
variety of ingredients. The Greeks were the first to use
mouthrinse made of urine. Yes, urine was promoted as a
mouthrinse in a 70 AD medical book of Dioscorides of
Anazarbus. The Romans preferred more exotic urine than
that of fellow Romans, thus importing Portuguese urine.
Those who lived in what is now India found the urine of a
child or a young cow to be the mouthwash of choice. Makes
you wonder how bad the breath was back then that the smell
of urine was an improvement.
Some dental products contain substances that do have a
positive effect on the source of bad breath. Chemicals used
to kill bacteria or neutralize volatile sulphur compounds
include chlorine dioxide, zinc, sodium chlorite, peroxide,
polyphenols, CPC, triclosan and chlorhexidine. Mouthrinses
containing these chemicals or natural xylitol will
reduce the level of free-floating bacteria in the mouth and
provide oral malodor protection for three to 10 hours. The
flavor is important when asking patients to comply with recommendations
for daily use. People prefer different tastes, so
it’s helpful to offer a variety of choices when recommending
fresh breath products.
Chewing gum stimulates salivary flow, which helps control
oral malodor. Despite the increased salivary flow, sorbitol-sweetened chewing gums feed the bacteria and
bacteria can produce acids from sorbitol. Chewing gums
sweetened only with xylitol provide no nutrition for the
bacteria and will reduce the accumulation of bacterial
biofilm in the mouth.
Another way to control oral malodor when infected tonsils
are the source of bad breath is a tonsillectomy or laser
cryptolysis to prevent the accumulation of bacteria or tonsillitis
within the crypts of the tonsils.
Future
Breath researchers are designing an artificial nose to
measure breath, thus taking the place of people sniffing
breath. New treatment approaches include probiotics, salivary
stimulators, and xylitol containing products. There are
two international breath related organization: International
Society of Breath Odor Research (ISBOR) targeting the
dental community, and the International Association of
Breath Research (IABR) a group focused on the diagnosis of
medical conditions through exhaled breath analysis. These
two organizations shared a joint symposium in 2009 and
also share a research journal, the Journal of Breath Research.
As these two organizations work closely in the future, we
will see exciting advances in breath diagnostics and new
therapies for eliminating bad breath. |