Perio
Reports Vol. 21 No. 7 |
Perio Reports provides easy-to-read research summaries on topics of specific interest to clinicians.
Perio Reports research summaries will be included in each issue to keep you on the cutting edge
of dental hygiene science.
|
Xylitol used in a nasal spray
Upper respiratory infections (URIs) are a common complaint
heard by primary care physicians. After colonization in
the nasopharynx, bacteria extend down the Eustachian canal
causing otitis media, into the sinuses and can be aspirated causing
bronchitis. The greatest use of antibiotics is for URIs and
the overuse in these cases becomes the primary source of antibiotic
resistance.
URIs have increased six percent each year since 1970, due in
part to increased use of daycare centers and over-the-counter use of
antihistamines and decongestants. Children in daycare experience
an average of six URIs per year. Physiologic washing of the
nasopharynx is accomplished by histamine-induced rhinorrhea. A
runny nose is nature’s way of washing out bacteria and toxins.
Antihistamines and decongestants stop the normal washing process
and have led to a three-fold increase in problems. In 1990, the cost
of treating ear infections was $3.5 billion dollars; in 1994, the cost
for asthma treatments was $5.8 billion.
Xylitol reduces the bacterial population significantly by interfering
with energy and acid production, leaving the bacteria unable to
adhere to each other or tissues. A side effect of xylitol chewing gum
studies was a 40 percent reduction in ear infections. Lab studies
using a five percent xylitol solution reduced adherence of Strep
pneumonia to nasal cells by 68 percent and Haemophilus influenza
by 50 percent. The osmolarity of xylitol reduces swelling and pulls
water from the tissue to wash the area.
Clinical cases of a five-month-old, an eight-year-old and a 42-
year-old showed clinically significant reductions in URIs when an
11 percent xylitol nasal wash was used three to four times per day.
Asthma was also reduced significantly.
Clinical Implications: Adding xylitol nasal-washing instructions
to oral hygiene instructions might provide patients with additional
preventive benefits.
Jones, A.: Intranasal Xylitol, Recurrent Otitis Meida, and Asthma: Report of Three Cases. Clin Pract of Alter Prac, 2: 112-117, 2001. |
|
Flossing with intention and a plan
Since periodontal disease begins interproximally,
cleaning in between is essential for effective prevention.
Despite this fact, compliance with flossing or
interdental cleaning is extremely low. In Germany,
floss sales predict only 2.2 percent of the general
population uses it. Studies show only nine percent of
university students floss.
According to the research, having the intention
to floss is not enough. A plan of action is also needed.
Graduate psychology students carried out this study
on the campus of Freie University in Berlin,
Germany. A total of 194 highly educated individuals
completed a questionnaire assessing flossing behavior
at the time of study enrollment and other questionnaires
were mailed to them at weeks two and eight.
Subjects received Oral B Satin Floss and printed
flossing instructions. Those randomly assigned to the
“planning” section spent three-minutes with a student
writing down their plan: when, where and how
they planned to floss. Control and planning groups
were further subdivided based on answers to questions
about flossing that identified those who were
still contemplating the benefits of flossing and those
who were intent on implementing flossing.
Compliance with flossing for two weeks was not
ideal. Those with intent to flossing who had a plan
flossed four times per week compared to those in the
control group who flossed three time per week.
Clinical Implications: Compliance with flossing is
consistently low, but helping patients make a plan
as to when, where and how they will floss might
lead to slightly better compliance.
Schüz, B., Wiedemann, A., Mallach, N., Scholz, U.:
Effects of a Short Behavioural Intervention for
Dental Flossing: Randomized-Controlled Trial on
Planning When, Where and How. J Clin Perio 36:
498-505, 2009. |
|
|
Topical doxycycline tested in furcations
Furcations don’t respond as well to treatment as single-rooted
teeth and are therefore at greater risk for further
attachment loss. Tooth loss is higher for teeth with furcation
involvement. Subgingival application of a 14 percent doxycycline
gel (available in Europe), has shown promise when compared
to scaling and root planing
(SRP) alone.
Researchers at University
Hospital in Heidleberg, Germany,
compared SRP alone and SRP with
doxycycline gel in furcations of
periodontal maintenance patients.
Plaque, probing, attachment and
bleeding scores were recorded at
baseline. All sites with probing
depths equal to or greater than
4mm were instrumented with a KaVo Sonicflex sonic scaler.
Following instrumentation, subjects were randomly assigned
to either receive the 14 percent doxycycline gel or not.
Five subjects had to leave the study for rescue treatment
because of attachment loss greater than 2mm since their last
visit. One person in the SRP group exited at six-months and
four people in the SRP plus doxycycline group exited, three at
three-months and one at six-months. Problems were not
always due to furcation involvement, as some single rooted
teeth presented with advancing disease and some with
endodontic problems.
At three months, slightly more improvement was evident
in the doxycycline group
compared to the control group.
This difference wasn’t carried over
to the six and 12 month evaluations.
Any site still measuring
4mm or more with bleeding was
re-instrumented. This applied to
75 percent of furcation sites.
Clinical Implications: Furcation
sites will likely require re-instrumentation
at each maintenance visit, despite the application
of doxycycline gel.
Dannewitz, B., Lippert, K., Lang, N., Tonetti, M., Eickholz, P.:
Supportive Periodontal Therapy of Furcation Sites: Non-Surgical
Instrumentation with and without Topical Doxycycline. J Clin
Perio 36: 514-522, 2009. |
|
Periodontal therapy reduces C-reactive protein
Cardiovascular disease is a leading cause of death today.
Patients who don’t respond to drugs for lowering blood pressure
are considered to have refractory hypertension. Periodontal disease
is associated with elevated plasma levels of IL-6, C-reactive
protein (CRP) and fibrinogen.
Researchers at the National Institute of Cardiology in Rio
de Janeiro, Brazil, provided non-surgical therapy to 11 patients
with refractory hypertension who also had severe periodontitis.
The control group of 11 patients with refractory hypertension
and severe periodontitis had their non-surgical therapy delayed
for three months. Clinical, demographic and blood tests were
done for all the patients at baseline and three months. Non-surgical
therapy included oral hygiene instructions, power scaling
with a KaVo sonic scaler, and hand instrumentation with Hu-Friedy Gracey curettes.
No time limit was placed on the therapy and patients were seen for four to six
visits over two weeks.
At baseline, both groups presented with similar clinical,
demographic and laboratory parameters. At three months, the
control group showed increased levels of CRP and IL-6, and
unchanged levels of fibrinogen. Those receiving non-surgical
therapy showed significant reductions in levels of CRP, IL-6 and
fibrinogen. All clinical parameters showed improvement, except
plaque levels. Perhaps this was due to only one session of oral
hygiene instruction.
Further research is needed to determine if these short-term
results are maintained long-term and to determine if periodontal
therapy provides a beneficial effect on hypertension.
Clinical
Implications: Non-surgical periodontal therapy
provides benefits beyond the gingiva, by reducing inflammatory
markers.
Vidal, F., Figueredo, C., Cordovil, I., Fischer, R.: Periodontal
Therapy Reduces Plasma Levels of Interleukin-6, C-Reactive
Protein, and Fibrinogen in Patients with Severe Periodontitis and
Refractory Arterial Hypertension. J Perio 80: 786-791, 2009. |
|
Oral lesions may be metastatic cancer
Oral metastatic tumors make up one
percent of malignant oral neoplasms and
might mimic pyogenic granuloma, peripheral
giant cell granuloma or fibroma. The
primary tumors are most often located in
the breast, lung, kidney, bone and colon.
Researchers in Spain and The Netherlands
evaluated several years of data from patient
charts to determine the survival rate for those
diagnosed with oral metastatic tumors. A
series of 39 patients ranging in age from eight to 90 years, the average being 62
years, were included in this retrospective study. The primary tumors for these
individuals included kidney, breast, lung, prostate, liver, colon, thyroid, esophagus
and cerebellum. Primary tumors in children tend to be associated with the
nervous system.
Gingival tumors were more frequent in the maxilla (86 percent vs 14 percent)
while osseous tumors were more prevalent in the mandible (78 percent vs 22 percent).
The average time between diagnosis of the primary tumor and evidence of
the oral lesion was 14 months. There was a wide range for the number of months
surviving after diagnosis of the oral metastasis, one month to 120 months, with
the average survival rate being six months.
One theory to explain metastasis to gingival tissues is the capillary rich network
found in chronically inflamed gingival tissue. However, the mechanism of
metastasis is poorly understood.
Clinical Implications: Gingival lesions seeming to be benign, inflammatory
lesions might in rare cases actually be oral metastatic lesions from a primary
tumor elsewhere in the body. Any suspect lesion require biopsy and a
histopathologic evaluation.
Seoane, J., Van der Waal, I., Van der Waal, R., Cameselle-Teijeiro, J., Antón, I.,
Tardio, A., Alcázar-Otero, J., Varela-Centelles, P., Diz, P.: Metastatic Tumours to the
Oral Cavity: A Survival Study with a Special Focus on Gingival Metastases. J Clin
Perio 36: 488-492, 2009. |
|
Oral probiotic lozenge reduces perio pathogens
Caries and periodontal disease are the most common infectious
diseases in humans. An emerging area of oral research
focuses on probiotics, which are live microorganisms that confer
beneficial effects on the balance of bacteria in the mouth.
The most common bacteria used in probiotics for gastrointestinal
disorders are Lactobacillus and bifidobacteria. For control of periodontal
pathogens, L. Salivarius strain WB21
was selected because it is resistant to gastric
acid, produces adhesion inhibitors
and antimicrobial components, which
should inhibit periodontal bacteria.
Researchers at Tohoku University
Graduate School of Dentistry in Sendai,
Miyagi Prefecture, Japan, compared
WE21 probiotic lozenge sweetened with
xylitol to a placebo xylitol lozenge.
Subjects in this eight-week study all
worked at the Wakamoto Pharmaceutical
Co. in Tokyo, Japan, the company
making the probiotic. Subjects were
instructed to place one lozenge, three
times each day, on their tongues and let it
dissolve without chewing.
Supra and subgingival plaque samples
were taken from the mesial surfaces
of six teeth in each of the 66 individuals.
Bacterial counts reduced for both
the control and test halves of the group.
Greater reductions were seen in the
WE21 group for five bacteria measured
in subgingival samples at four weeks.
At eight weeks, both groups showed
similar reductions. Perhaps the xylitol
played a role as well as the Hawthorne
Effect of better compliance with oral
hygiene because of participation in a
research study.
Concern was raised by the authors
about the potential for WE21 to contribute
to caries formation, by increasing
the Lactobacillus count in the mouth.
Clinical Implications: Probiotics might
be helpful in reducing and controlling
periodontal pathogens.
Mayanagi, G., Kimura, M., Nakaya, S, |
|