Message Boards
Today's Active Topics Today's Active Cases Browse Forum Categories My Recent Activity My Messages Private Groups My Bookmarks My Subscriptions
Today's Active Images Today's Active Polls Most Active Topics Global Townie Map Advanced Message Board Search Message Board Terms of Use

Hygienetown: Dental Hygienist Shortage 2026

Start Discussion
Categories: Hygiene;
Hygienetown: Dental Hygienist Shortage 2026

Wages, temp culture, supragingival scaling laws, and how Townies are adapting

If you want to start a lively argument at any dental meeting, do not bring up implants, occlusion, or fluoride. Just say two words: hygienist shortage. The room will instantly divide into camps, and everyone will have a story that sounds too crazy to be real, except it is.

Townies say the shortage remains very real in many markets, but it is uneven. In some areas, job ads at $70 an hour get zero applicants. In others, $40 an hour brings in a pile of resumes, but applicants refuse assisted hygiene at that rate. Some regions are still booked several months in advance for new-patient hygiene. Others are seeing a small uptick in applications, especially when a practice can filter through unusual candidate pools like foreign-trained dentists who pick up hygiene licensure as a bridge job.

The recurring theme is that the shortage is not just about headcount. It is about hours, expectations, and power.

The pandemic accelerated exits, and retirement kept the door spinning. Then the “Uberization” of hygiene hit. Temp apps made it easy to chase the highest day rate, pick hours like a menu, and avoid the sticky parts of long-term practice life. That sticky part is relationships, follow-ups, and accountability. Patients love continuity. Temporary staffing does not.

Townies also say the balance of power shifted hard toward hygienists, and many practices responded by tolerating behavior they would have never accepted in the past. The phrase that comes up repeatedly is “hostage.” When you are booked out six months and cannot find coverage, you keep the team member who makes everyone miserable because the alternative is canceling hygiene for weeks and watching patients drift away. It becomes a constant mental math problem. Is it worth losing the employee over this, or do we swallow it and keep the schedule alive?

That pressure is pushing practice owners into survival mode. Some are dropping plans, or at least considering it, because $60 an hour plus benefits does not pencil when reimbursements are anchored to old fee schedules and third-party write-offs. Townies say the whiplash is the most maddening part. This was not a gradual shift over decades. It felt like an overnight change that blew up a business model built on predictable hygiene capacity.

When the math does not work, people innovate.

Townies say one of the most successful adaptations is to rethink the new-patient entry point. Instead of waiting months for a hygiene opening, new patients come through the doctor side fast. They get records, a limited or comp exam, and a prophy slot sooner, sometimes with the doctor doing the visit and the team handling the rest. It keeps patients from feeling ignored, increases diagnosis and case acceptance, and protects relationships. Clean teeth are nice. Feeling seen is better.

Others are optimizing hygiene workflow to make the job easier and more attractive. Townies describe streamlined setups with dedicated instrument sets, dedicated prophy and piezo handpieces per patient, rolling carts that keep everything at arm’s reach, and enough sterilizer capacity that the hygienist never has to touch the sterilization bottleneck. The punchline is simple. Instead of paying more for the same chaos, remove the chaos. In at least one practice story, the “raise” was not money. It was time. Shorter blocks, same pay, more life. That is a recruiting ad that writes itself.

Then comes the political conversation. Townies say the obvious pressure valve is scope. Why can an assistant remove temporaries, clean cement, pack cord, scan preps, and place composites, but cannot coronal polish or do supragingival scaling in many states? The logic drives people nuts. Many believe that assistant supragingival scaling legislation, framed as access to care, is inevitable, especially as patients wait months for basic preventive services.

Not everyone agrees on where that leads. Some see it as a necessary evolution. Others worry it will degrade care quality or worsen professional tension. But most agree on one point. If organized dentistry does not move faster, legislatures will. Townies are frustrated with what feels like slow, distant advocacy. The American Dental Association is criticized for priorities that do not seem tied to private practice survival, and the conversation gets even louder when people see large reserve expenditures and wonder where the return is for the dentist in the operatory trying to staff a hygiene schedule.

There is also a cultural gap emerging between academia and private practice. Townies describe hygienists trained in strict black-and-white rules who fear licensing consequences, then collide with real-world dentistry, where patients refuse X-rays, life happens, and care must move forward safely without turning every case into a multi-visit perfection plan. The dentist is responsible for diagnosis and risk, yet the hygienist often feels the threat. That mismatch creates conflict and resentment on both sides.

Patients, of course, are watching this play out without caring about any of our internal politics. They just want their teeth cleaned. So, the best communication strategy is calm transparency. Tell them the truth early: Hygiene availability is limited. Offer them options. Put them on a priority list. Offer an earlier doctor visit for evaluation and records. Explain that preventive care is still the goal, but access is tight, and you are managing it responsibly. Patients forgive delay more easily than they forgive silence.

If there is a single takeaway from Townies, it is this: The shortage is not one problem but a stack of problems. Wages, write offs, temp culture, school capacity, retirement, burnout, scope laws, and leadership all collide in the same operatory. The practices that will win are the ones that stop waiting for the market to return to 2019 and start designing a model that works in 2026.

If you could change one thing tomorrow to stabilize your hygiene department, would you change compensation, scheduling, scope laws, or your entire new patient workflow?
Want to hear multiple perspectives?
Join the discussion with your peers here on Dentaltown (click View Comments below) and then see what hygienists are saying about this topic on Hygienetown by clicking the button below.

Join the Conversation on Hygienetown!

More In Hygiene
Are You Staying Ahead of the Ultrasonic Curve?
Are You Staying Ahead of the Ultrasonic Curve?
Dani Botbyl, RDH
CE Credits: 1.5
Dental Hygiene Instruments...What’s Hot, What’s Not, you be the Judge.
Dental Hygiene Instruments...What’s Hot, What’s Not, you be the...
Judy Bendit RDH.
CE Credits: 1.5
Hygienetown: Dental Hygienist Shortage 2026
Hygienetown: Dental Hygienist Shortage 2026
February 2026
Hygienetown: The Future of Preventive Care
Hygienetown: The Future of Preventive Care
January 2026
Dentaltown Magazine
January 2026
Dentaltown Magazine January 2026 Read Current Issue Read Archived Issues
Sponsors
Townie Perks
Townie® Poll
Who primarily handles HR responsibilities in your practice?
  
Related Articles
2023 Dental Townie Choice Awards
2023 Dental Townie Choice Awards
December 2023
2025 Townie Choice Award Winners
2025 Townie Choice Award Winners
December 2025
SDF Essentials
SDF Essentials
by Dr. Roopwant Kaur
February 2025
Site Menu
Message Boards Magazine Continuing Education Podcasts Blogs Classifieds Dental News Events Townie® Poll Ebooks Townie Choice Awards
Company Info
Contact Us Advertise With Us Howard Farran DDS, MBA Policies and Agreements
Site Help
The Dentaltown Team, Farran Media Support
Phone: +1-480-445-9710
Email: support@dentaltown.com
©2026 Dentaltown, a division of Farran Media • All Rights Reserved
9633 S. 48th Street Suite 200 • Phoenix, AZ 85044 • Phone:+1-480-598-0001 • Fax:+1-480-598-3450