Our payment processor is currently undergoing maintenance. Purchases will have intermittent availability. Failed purchases are not charged.
We apologize for the inconvenience. Thank you for your patience.

Firegang Dental Marketing | Dental Practice Growth, SEO & Marketing
Firegang Dental Marketing | Dental Practice Growth, SEO & Marketing
Firegang Dental Marketing shares Dental SEO, Google Ads, AI search, website, reputation management, and patient growth strategies.
Melanie Ariail

Why Firegang Dental Marketing Says Better Reviews Don't Always Mean Better Google Rankings

Why Firegang Dental Marketing Says Better Reviews Don't Always Mean Better Google Rankings

10/2/2026 1:19:00 PM   |   Comments: 0   |   Views: 41


Few things are more frustrating for a dental practice owner than searching Google and seeing a competitor ranking above you when your practice has more reviews, a higher star rating, or both.

It raises an obvious question: If Google reviews matter so much, why is a practice with worse reviews outranking yours?

The answer is that reviews are only one part of the equation.

At Firegang Dental Marketing, we often see dental practices focus heavily on review count while overlooking other factors that can have a major impact on local search visibility. Google considers a much broader picture when determining which practices appear at the top of local search results.

Why Can a Competitor With Worse Reviews Rank Higher on Google?

Google's local search results are influenced primarily by three areas: relevance, distance, and prominence.

That means a competitor may have fewer reviews but still have stronger overall SEO signals. Their website may be more authoritative, their content may better match what patients are searching for, they may have stronger backlinks, or their location may simply be more relevant to the person conducting the search.

Reviews matter, but they do not operate in isolation.

5 Reasons a Competitor May Be Ranking Higher on Google

1. Their Dental Website Is Better Optimized

A strong dental website does much more than look professional.

Site speed, mobile usability, technical structure, service pages, local content, internal linking, and overall user experience can all affect how well Google understands and ranks a dental practice.

Content is becoming especially important as patients increasingly search through both traditional search engines and AI-powered platforms. Creating useful content that directly answers patient questions can help a practice build visibility across Google as well as emerging AI search experiences for dentists.

A practice can have hundreds of five-star reviews and still struggle if the website supporting its online presence is outdated, slow, or lacking relevant content.

2. They Have Stronger Backlinks and Online Authority

Backlinks are links from other websites pointing to a dental practice's website.

Not all backlinks are equal. Links from reputable organizations, news publications, professional associations, local businesses, community organizations, and relevant directories can help establish authority.

A competitor may have fewer patient reviews but significantly stronger authority across the web.

That advantage is not always obvious when looking at their Google Business Profile, but it can make a meaningful difference in organic and local search visibility.

3. Their Google Business Profile Is Better Optimized

A complete Google Business Profile helps Google better understand what a dental practice offers and when it should appear in relevant searches.

Categories, services, business descriptions, hours, photos, accurate contact information, and other profile details all help establish relevance.

Practices should also respond to patient reviews and regularly make sure the information appearing on their profile remains accurate.

A competitor with fewer reviews may simply be giving Google clearer information about its services, location, and patients.

4. Their Online Reputation Is More Consistent

Having a high star rating is valuable, but dental practices should think beyond the average number displayed beside their name.

An effective dental reputation management strategy should focus on consistently generating legitimate feedback from patients rather than collecting a large number of reviews during one short period and then stopping.

Google confirms that positive ratings and review volume can contribute to local prominence, but reviews still work alongside many other SEO signals.

If you are wondering how many Google reviews a dentist needs, the better question may be whether your overall online presence is competitive within your specific market.

5. Their Website Better Matches the Patient's Search

Relevance can be one of the biggest differences between two competing dental practices.

Imagine a patient searching for:

"emergency dentist near me"

One practice may have a 4.9-star rating and hundreds of reviews but barely mention emergency dentistry on its website.

Another practice may have a 4.6-star rating but have a detailed emergency dentistry page, relevant Google Business Profile services, locally optimized content, and other signals clearly connecting the practice with emergency dental care.

For that particular search, the lower-rated practice may be more relevant.

The same principle applies to searches involving dental implants, Invisalign, cosmetic dentistry, sedation dentistry, dentures, or virtually any other dental service.

Why More Reviews May Not Solve the Problem

When a competitor is outranking your practice, the natural reaction may be to generate more reviews.

That may help, but it is not always the solution.

If the real problem is weak website authority, poor technical performance, missing service content, limited backlinks, or ineffective local optimization, another 50 five-star reviews may not address the underlying issue.

This is why successful dental SEO requires looking at the entire competitive landscape.

You need to understand what the practices ranking above you are doing differently.

That includes evaluating:
  • Website structure and technical SEO
  • Local service content
  • Google Business Profile optimization
  • Backlink authority
  • Online citations
  • Review quantity and quality
  • Local relevance
  • Competitor content strategies
  • Mobile performance and site speed
Looking at each area together can reveal why one practice is consistently winning valuable searches.

How Dentists Can Improve Their Google Rankings

Improving local search visibility usually requires several strategies working together rather than one quick fix.

A comprehensive approach may include conducting a technical website audit, improving service pages, optimizing local keywords, strengthening a Google Business Profile, developing authoritative content, earning relevant backlinks, and creating an ongoing review generation process.

The specific strategy should depend on the competitive environment surrounding each practice.

A dentist in a small market may face very different SEO challenges than a practice competing against dozens of dentists in a large metro area.

That is also why choosing the best dental marketing company for your practice should involve more than simply asking whether the company offers SEO. Dental marketing requires understanding patient search behavior, local competition, practice goals, service mix, and how all of those factors work together to generate measurable growth.

Frequently Asked Questions About Dental Google Rankings

Can a Dentist With Fewer Reviews Rank Higher on Google?

Yes. Reviews are an important local search signal, but Google also evaluates relevance, distance, prominence, website authority, backlinks, business information, and other factors. A practice with fewer reviews can therefore rank above a practice with a stronger average rating.

Do Google Reviews Help Dental SEO?

Yes. Review quantity and positive ratings can contribute to local prominence. However, reviews should be part of a broader dental SEO strategy rather than treated as the only factor affecting rankings.

Why Did My Dental Practice Drop in Google Rankings?

Ranking changes can happen for several reasons, including competitor improvements, changes to your website, technical SEO issues, Google Business Profile changes, new content from competing practices, algorithm updates, and differences in patient search behavior.

How Can a Dentist Outrank Local Competitors?

Start by comparing your website, Google Business Profile, content, backlinks, reviews, and local optimization against the practices currently ranking above you. Identifying the largest gaps makes it easier to determine where your marketing efforts should be focused.

Should I Focus on Reviews or SEO?

Both matter. Reviews strengthen your online reputation and can contribute to local prominence, while SEO helps search engines understand your services, authority, location, and relevance. The strongest strategy combines reputation management with comprehensive local and organic SEO.

The Bottom Line

A competitor with worse reviews ranking above your dental practice does not mean reviews are unimportant.

It usually means the competitor is stronger somewhere else.

Their advantage may come from website authority, backlinks, content, local relevance, Google Business Profile optimization, location, or several factors working together.

Instead of trying to solve the problem with reviews alone, look at the entire competitive picture.

At Firegang Dental Marketing, we help dental practices identify where they may be losing visibility and build strategies designed to turn marketing into measurable practice growth.

If you're unsure why competing practices are appearing above yours, a competitive analysis can help identify the gaps.

Book a complimentary Practice Growth Assessment to take a closer look at your practice's marketing and opportunities for growth.
You must be logged in to view comments.
Total Blog Activity
997
Total Bloggers
13,451
Total Blog Posts
4,671
Total Podcasts
1,788
Total Videos
Sponsors
Townie Perks