Father of Five’s Implant Death Tied to Sedation Drugs; Family Pushes Florida Law Change
Edited by Dentaltown staff
Anthony DiMatteo’s wife dropped him off for a full-mouth dental implant procedure shortly before 7 a.m. About three hours later, police called to tell her he was being rushed to a hospital.
DiMatteo, a father of five, was later determined to be brain dead, and he died Sept. 17, 2024. Now his wife, Sarah DiMatteo, and the family’s attorney, Mike Grife, are pushing to change how Florida handles IV sedation in dental offices.
The St. Lucie County Medical Examiner’s Office attributed his death to complications from fentanyl, midazolam, and dexmedetomidine administered during the procedure at a Port St. Lucie dental office. It ruled the death accidental and listed cardiovascular disease, hypertension, and diabetes as contributing factors.
According to his wife, DiMatteo had spent years dealing with cracked, loose, and missing teeth that left him in pain and self-conscious about a smile he loved to share. The work was supposed to be finished in a single day.
She said he had a complex medical history and that she believes more scrutiny should have gone into whether he was an appropriate candidate for sedation. The family, she said, trusted the process without asking those questions.
Florida lets dentists who meet training requirements obtain permits to administer moderate IV sedation, and state records show DiMatteo’s dentist holds an active moderate sedation permit from the Florida Department of Health. WPBF’s report did not name the dentist or mention a lawsuit, disciplinary complaint, or filed bill.
The family wants a law requiring a dedicated anesthesia professional or other qualified provider to monitor patients under IV sedation during dental procedures, rather than allowing the operating dentist to oversee both the procedure and the sedation. Grife pointed to anesthesiologists and certified registered nurse anesthetists as the kind of specially trained providers who should be there to protect the patient.
He argues that asking one person to perform the procedure, monitor the sedation, and respond to complications creates unnecessary risk. “Imagine trying to juggle all those things at once,” he said. He added that the family believes DiMatteo’s death was preventable and that he would still be alive if proper safeguards had been in place.
The DiMatteos aren’t the first family to make that case after an implant patient’s death. In Arizona, the parents of 40-year-old Derek Swanson called for a two-provider system after their son suffered complications during a March 2023 implant procedure at a Scottsdale oral surgery practice and was taken off life support a week later. The Maricopa County Medical Examiner attributed his death to complications of anesthesia administration.
The Swansons’ wrongful death lawsuit alleged a series of anesthesia failures that left their son without enough oxygen. The dentist’s attorneys denied negligence, and the case settled confidentially in December 2025. At the time, Arizona did not require a separate anesthesia provider.
In a separate implant death case, the Florida Board of Dentistry voted unanimously on Nov. 6 to revoke the license of Ponte Vedra dentist Dr. Francesco Sebastiani over a 2023 patient death, rejecting an administrative law judge’s recommendation to dismiss the case. The health department had accused him of failing to adequately monitor the patient and of performing the surgery in a dental office rather than a hospital.
His attorney said he plans to appeal. Two other complaints against Sebastiani remain pending, including one tied to a second patient’s 2025 death during an implant procedure, which a medical examiner ruled accidental.
Florida already requires a team approach for moderate sedation. Under the Board of Dentistry’s rules, administering it takes at least three people: the operating dentist, a person responsible for monitoring the patient, and a person assisting the dentist. The dentist and assisting staff need basic life support certification, and the dentist must also be current in Advanced Cardiac Life Support.
What Florida doesn’t require is that the person monitoring the patient be a separately licensed anesthesia professional, such as an anesthesiologist or certified registered nurse anesthetist. That’s the piece the DiMatteo family wants to change.
That would be a meaningful shift from Florida’s office-team model, and it’s the same question the Swansons raised in Arizona: whether a trained dentist should keep administering sedation during treatment while a team member monitors, or whether IV sedation should require another licensed provider dedicated to anesthesia. Patient selection belongs in the discussion, too, given the contributing conditions listed in DiMatteo’s medical examiner report.
If your state required a separately licensed anesthesia provider for every IV sedation case, would your full-arch workflow survive the change, or are you already using that model?
Sources:
WPBF 25 News, “Family calls for sedation law changes after father’s death during dental procedure,” Nov. 16, 2026: wpbf.com/article/family-calls-for-sedation-law-changes
ABC15 Arizona (KNXV), “Family settles wrongful death lawsuit after son dies from dental anesthesia complications,” Dec. 22, 2025: abc15.com/news/family-settles-wrongful-death-lawsuit
First Coast News (WTLV), “Florida Board of Dentistry votes to revoke Ponte Vedra dentist’s license following patient’s death,” Nov. 6, 2026: firstcoastnews.com/article/news/local/florida-board-of-dentistry-revokes
Florida Administrative Code, Rule 64B5-14.003, “Training, Education, Certification, and Requirements for Issuance of Permits,” effective Aug. 19, 2026: flrules.org/gateway/RuleNo.asp?ID=64B5-14.003
