How Dentists Can Save Money on Dental Supplies

Posted: October 26, 2026
By Howard Farran, DDS, MBA

How Dentists Can Save Money on Dental Supplies: Best Buying Groups, Suppliers and Procurement Strategies

Ask a room full of dentists where to buy supplies and you will quickly hear the same names. Henry Schein. Patterson. Benco. Darby. Safco. Net32. Frontier. Then come the buying groups, Synergy, Carabelli Club, Unified Smiles and others. Add procurement platforms such as Dentira, Method, Torch, Alara and ZenOne, and what used to be a simple question becomes surprisingly complicated.

The wrong question is, “Who has the cheapest dental supplies?”

There probably is no single answer. Dental pricing varies by practice, purchasing volume, negotiated contracts, product mix, geography and timing. A distributor that wins on anesthetic may lose on composite. A buying group that crushes the market on implants may be mediocre on CAD/CAM blocks. One practice may save tens of thousands of dollars through Carabelli while another compares the same program with its existing negotiated prices and finds almost no advantage. Those outcomes can all be true at the same time.

Dentaltown has provided an unusually revealing laboratory for watching this play out. In discussions comparing Synergy Dental Partners and MB2 Dental’s Carabelli Club, dentists have reported dramatically different results. Some praise Synergy’s pricing through Darby and Brasseler. Others say Carabelli’s Henry Schein, Patterson, laboratory, Invisalign and equipment service arrangements saved them substantially more. One Townie reported that Carabelli repriced his previous year’s Schein purchases and calculated savings of about $42,000. Months later, Benco analyzed his business and reportedly offered pricing another 22% below the Carabelli level because his large practice qualified for Benco’s higher volume pricing tier.

That story should end the argument over which company is universally cheapest. Competitive bidding won.

Buying groups work because thousands of independent dentists collectively possess more negotiating power than one dentist walking into a sales representative’s territory alone. The concept is economically real. In 2019, a Federal Trade Commission administrative decision found that Benco and Patterson had conspired to refuse discounts to, or otherwise compete for, dental buying group business. The allegations against Henry Schein were dismissed. The case is an unusually concrete reminder that aggregated purchasing power can materially affect dental supply pricing.

Today’s GPOs use that principle differently. Synergy says its network includes more than 5,500 offices and more than 65 vendor partners. It often concentrates purchasing with one preferred supplier in a category to increase negotiating power, and members receive access to Method procurement technology. Carabelli takes a broader approach. MB2 Dental opened part of the purchasing ecosystem it developed for its affiliated practices to independent dentists. Membership currently costs $199 per month, or $1,990 for the first annual term, and includes vendor pricing, education, other business benefits and complimentary access to Dentira. Unified Smiles is another sizable independent dentist GPO, currently advertising more than 1,500 dentists and more than 100 vendor relationships.

But GPOs are only one part of the market. Traditional distributors such as Henry Schein, Patterson, Benco and Darby compete with Safco, Frontier Dental, DHP, DC Dental, Dental City, Pearson, Burkhart, Atlanta Dental and regional dealers. Marketplaces such as Net32 introduce another source of competition. Manufacturers may also sell directly or through special programs. Then there is an expanding software layer designed to make price comparison, ordering, inventory and budgeting easier.

Torch Dental, for example, says more than 3,000 independent practices use its platform to purchase across more than 25 authorized vendors. Torch reports average supply savings of about 16%, although that figure comes from the company rather than an independent study. Its more interesting feature may be the process itself. Torch asks practices for 12 months of purchasing history and produces a line by line comparison against the prices available through its system.

ZenOne combines procurement and inventory management and currently charges $99 per month. It also discloses how it gets paid, including commissions from selected distribution partners. That raises a question every dentist should ask any purchasing platform: Who pays you, and can that payment influence what you show me?

Dentira represents the enterprise end of this evolution. What began as a way to compare prices across existing supplier accounts has expanded into purchasing controls, inventory, invoice reconciliation, accounts payable and laboratory management. Large organizations such as Heartland Dental use it because a DSO with hundreds or thousands of offices has a different problem from a solo dentist. Headquarters needs to know what every office is buying, whether it is on formulary, whether negotiated pricing is actually being received and whether inventory is disappearing into cabinets faster than patients can consume it. Procurement software increasingly manages the entire flow of money rather than simply locating cheap gloves.

For the independent dentist, however, sophisticated software should not distract from a much simpler metric. Dental supplies and inventory are often benchmarked around 5% to 6% of collections, while recognizing that every practice differs. A surgical or implant heavy practice may legitimately spend more than a bread and butter restorative office. The percentage is best used as a warning light. If a general practice is spending 8% or 9% of collections on clinical supplies, somebody should be asking why.

That question matters even more because supply inflation has been real. Dental equipment and supply prices in 2026 were roughly 23% higher than they were in January 2021. Dentists cannot control inflation, but they can control whether the practice notices price increases. A product that quietly rises from $42 to $47 and then to $52 rarely creates an emergency meeting. Multiply that creep across hundreds of SKUs and several years, and it becomes real money.

This is why percentage discounts can be misleading. “Forty percent off” sounds impressive until you ask, forty percent off what? Manufacturer suggested retail price, catalog price, yesterday’s price, or the price nobody actually pays? The number that matters is total procurement cost. That includes the actual products, shipping, handling, hazardous material fees, membership fees, software subscriptions, rebates, credits, staff time, emergency orders, excess inventory, expired products, returns and waste.

A cheap product that expires unused is expensive. A distributor that saves $4,000 but requires $6,000 worth of staff time to constantly comparison shop is expensive. A bargain restorative material that creates remakes is spectacularly expensive.

Inventory deserves nearly as much attention as price. Dental offices have an astonishing ability to turn money into drawers full of stuff. One associate likes one composite, another prefers a different bonding system, hygiene orders its favorite prophy paste, somebody finds a three for two promotion and suddenly the practice owns enough material to survive a blockade. Large DSOs reduce purchasing costs partly through bargaining power, but they also standardize formularies. Independent dentists can copy that lesson without selling their practices.

Start by identifying the products consuming the most dollars annually. Every dentist knows the price of some memorable item such as gloves, but many do not know the 20 or 30 SKUs responsible for the largest portion of annual supply spending. Those products deserve far more attention than the cheap disposable everyone likes to debate. Saving 30% on something the practice buys twice a year accomplishes little. Saving 10% on a category consuming $40,000 annually gets your attention.

The same discipline should apply to expensive categories outside routine supplies. Laboratories, implants, bone grafting materials, aligners, CAD/CAM blocks, endodontics, equipment and equipment service should be analyzed separately. A purchasing organization may save $4,000 on consumables and then save another $20,000 on Invisalign or laboratory work. Another may win supplies but lose badly on implants. Looking only at gloves, masks and sterilization pouches can produce the right answer to an insignificant question.

There is also a point where cost cutting becomes foolish. Marketplace pricing can be especially attractive for commodity disposables, but clinicians should distinguish a patient bib from a bonding agent, anesthetic cartridge, cement, implant or graft material. For anything whose authenticity, storage conditions or performance can affect treatment, know who actually supplied the product and whether the seller is authorized. Saving money loses its appeal quickly when the product sitting in a patient’s mouth is the thing you are unsure about.

The most useful purchasing exercise for almost any practice is remarkably simple. Export the previous 12 months of purchases with every SKU, quantity and actual price paid. Include shipping and other charges. Send exactly the same purchasing file to several serious competitors. That might include your incumbent distributor, Synergy, Carabelli, Unified Smiles, Safco, Torch or whatever combination fits your practice. Ask each one to reprice the identical basket.

Do not accept ten cherry picked products showing spectacular savings. If the practice spent $90,000 last year, ask what the same $90,000 basket would have cost through the proposed system. Then compare the ancillary categories that matter to your office. Add membership costs. Add shipping. Consider staff time. Run the winner for several months and compare actual invoices with the promises.

That is the dental supply Pepsi Challenge.

The deeper lesson is that supply procurement should be managed like any other part of the business. A good office probably does not need blind loyalty to one supplier, nor does it need the dentist spending Sunday afternoon comparing 14 websites. It needs a controlled formulary, competitive pressure between suppliers, visibility into price changes, disciplined inventory, clear ordering authority and technology where the time savings justify the cost.

Know your total clinical supply expense as a percentage of collections. Know whether that number is rising or falling. Know which categories are driving it. Then make suppliers, GPOs and procurement platforms compete for the privilege of lowering it.

If every dental supplier had to reprice your exact last 12 months of purchases, who would really be cheapest?

Join the Conversation!



How Dentists Can Save Money on Dental Supplies

Industry Benchmarks and Dental Supply Economics

American Dental Association, Dental Supplies and Inventory Control https://www.ada.org/resources/practice/practice-management/dental-supplies-inventory-control

American Dental Association Health Policy Institute, State of the U.S. Dental Economy, Q2 2026 https://www.ada.org/-/media/project/ada-organization/ada/ada-org/files/resources/research/hpi/state_us_dental_economy_q22026.pdf

Dental Buying Groups

Synergy Dental Partners, About and Membership Network https://thesynergydentalpartners.com/about/

Carabelli Club by MB2 Dental, Membership and Pricing https://www.carabelliclub.com/pricing/

Carabelli Club, One Year of Helping Dentists Save More and Grow Smarter https://www.carabelliclub.com/blog/one-year-of-helping-dentists-save-more-and-grow-smarter/

MB2 Dental, Carabelli Club Launch and Strategy for Independent Dentists https://mb2dental.com/blog/mb2-dental-launches-carabelli-club-empowering-independent-dentists-with-premier-membership-benefits/

Unified Smiles, Dental GPO Membership, Pricing and Vendor Network https://unifiedsmiles.com/join

Dental Procurement and Supply Management Platforms

Dentira, Dental Procurement and Spend Management Platform https://www.dentira.com/

Torch Dental, Dental Supply Procurement Platform https://torchdental.com/

Torch Dental, Pricing Analysis and Supply Savings https://torchdental.com/pricing/

Method, Price Creep and Dental Supply Cost Management https://www.methodusa.com/resources/price-creep-how-dental-practices-can-stem-the-tide-of-lost-money

ZenOne, Dental Inventory and Procurement Software Pricing https://www.zenone.com/pricing/

Alara, Dental Supply Price Comparison Platform https://alaradental.com/

Dental Suppliers and Marketplaces

Net32, Dental Supply Marketplace https://www.net32.com/

Net32, Dental Supply Vendor Directory https://www.net32.com/vendor

Safco Dental Supply, Shipping, Pricing Comparisons and Purchasing Information https://www.safcodental.com/about-us/faq

Federal Trade Commission

Federal Trade Commission, Benco Dental and Patterson Dental Buying Group Antitrust Decision https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2019/11/dental-products-distributors-benco-dental-supply-company-patterson-companies-inc-decline-appeal-alj


Views: 56
Sponsors
Townie Perks