Is Dentistry Still a Good Career in 2026? What Dentaltown’s 2008 Predictions Got Right and Wrong

Posted: October 26, 2026
By Howard Farran, DDS, MBA

Is Dentistry Still a Good Career in 2026? What Dentaltown’s 2008 Predictions Got Right and Wrong

On February 9, 2008, a Dentaltown member named Avees started a thread called “This is NOT the best time to practice ……..” and challenged one of dentistry’s favorite narratives: that dentists had never had it so good. The thread exploded into hundreds of replies about the economy, PPOs, corporate dentistry, student debt, technology, staff, case acceptance, Baby Boomers, endodontics, fees, overhead, and whether the pessimists were simply making excuses.

Nearly nineteen years later, the fascinating part is not deciding who won. It is seeing how intelligent dentists forecast the future when the future is still hidden. The thread contains recency bias, survivorship bias, anecdotes posing as averages, sales incentives, optimism bias, pessimism bias, status signaling, false precision, and the tendency to treat one dentist’s local market as if it represents the entire profession. It also contains some remarkably good predictions.

The first thing hindsight does is vindicate Avees on timing. He posted in February 2008 worried that the economy was weakening. We now know the United States had already entered the Great Recession in December 2007. The National Bureau of Economic Research did not officially announce that turning point until December 1, 2008. NBER later determined that the recession ended in June 2009, after 18 months.

Dental data confirm that the pain reached the operatory. ADA Health Policy Institute data show that 20.5 percent of private practice dentists said they were “not busy enough” in 2007. That rose to 24.3 percent in 2008, 32.9 percent in 2009, 33.0 percent in 2010, and 38.0 percent in 2011. By 2019, the figure had fallen to 18.1 percent. A 2019 JADA study by Albert H. Guay and Andrew Blatz likewise found that general dental visits declined during the Great Recession, reaching 38.4 percent of the population in 2010, while orthodontic visits fell to 2.5 percent.

So Avees gets a strong PASS on one central claim: dentistry is recession resistant, not recession proof. But the thread repeatedly made a much larger leap from “the economy is weakening” to “dentistry may no longer be a great profession.” That did not survive the evidence.

Dentistry remains a high income occupation by American standards. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports a median annual wage of $176,110 for dentists in May 2025, compared with $50,980 across all U.S. occupations, and projects dentist employment to grow 6 percent through 2035. ADA data put average 2025 private practice net income at $215,320 for general dentists. But high income does not mean practice ownership became easier. The traditional owner model became financially tighter.

The ADA’s 2025 workforce report shows inflation adjusted average annual net income for general dentists falling from $267,168 in 2010 to $207,980 in 2024, expressed in 2024 dollars. Comparing the pooled periods of 2015 through 2019 and 2020 through 2024, inflation adjusted median GP revenue per dentist declined slightly, expenses increased, and median income fell 13.2 percent, from $230,353 to $200,000.

The ADA’s second quarter 2026 dental economy report makes the mechanism even clearer. Since January 2021, prices for dental equipment and supplies increased 23 percent and hourly earnings for dental office employees increased 23 percent, while overall inflation rose 27 percent. Dental reimbursement across all payer types increased only 19 percent. The ADA calls the result a “fiscal squeeze,” which may be the best description of the modern dental practice economy.

This matters because being busy is not the same thing as being profitable. In the second quarter of 2026, only 26 percent of dentists said they were not busy enough, while new patient wait times averaged 13.9 days. Yet reimbursement continued to trail costs. A full schedule does not repeal arithmetic.

That also changes how we should interpret the old PPO argument. In 2008, it was reasonable to say that an empty chair produces nothing and a discounted patient can be better than no patient. That remains basic marginal economics. But a discounted patient only helps if the revenue exceeds the incremental cost and the chair is truly excess capacity. When hygienists are scarce, wages are rising, and contracted fees lag inflation, filling scarce capacity with the lowest paying plan can become an expensive way to brag that the schedule is full.

Dentists appear to recognize this. At the end of 2024, 40.7 percent of owner dentists said they were likely to drop some insurance networks in 2025. Staffing was the top expected challenge at 62.2 percent, followed by insurance reimbursement and denials at 57.6 percent and rising overhead at 45.7 percent.

One of the strongest parts of my own 2008 argument was that labor matters. Dentists can spend hours saving pennies on supplies while ignoring the economics of payroll and delegation. That principle aged extremely well. The exact formulas I used did not.

My old claim that roughly 80 percent of dental costs were variable and 20 percent fixed was too neat to be a universal accounting rule. My 2 receptionists, 2 hygienists, 2 assistants, 1 dentist staffing formula may have worked at Today’s Dental, but it was never an economic law. Automation, outsourcing, centralized billing, online scheduling, multi doctor groups, expanded functions, DSOs, and AI have changed the staffing equation enormously.

The enduring principle is more useful: labor is both a cost and a productive asset. In early 2026, only 60.3 percent of dentists reported having enough hygienists, and 90.5 percent of those recruiting them said hiring was very or extremely difficult. During the Great Recession, many dentists had staff and chairs but not enough patients. In 2026, many practices have patients and chairs but not enough people. Dentistry ran into a capacity bottleneck.

Another major prediction from the old thread failed badly: the idea that Baby Boomer retirements would create a national dentist shortage because there would not be enough younger dentists to replace them. As of 2025, the ADA counted 205,088 professionally active dentists, or 60.0 dentists per 100,000 people. The average dentist retirement age increased from 64.7 in 2001 to 68.7 in 2024. Dentists stayed in practice longer than many forecasts assumed.

Meanwhile, dental education expanded to 79 accredited U.S. dental schools, 28,925 predoctoral students in 2025 to 2026, and 7,015 graduates in 2025. The retirement wave met a much larger pipeline than many expected.

But Ryan Swain’s argument that “WHERE?” matters more than “WHEN?” aged beautifully. The national average hides enormous geographic differences. ADA data show roughly 64.7 dentists per 100,000 people in urban counties in 2024 compared with 32.7 in rural counties. HRSA still identifies tens of millions of Americans within designated dental shortage areas and populations. America can have intense competition in an affluent suburb and severe access shortages a few hours away.

This is why “need” and “economic demand” must be separated. A community can have enormous untreated disease and still be difficult for private practice if patients lack income, meaningful benefits, or access. A seemingly saturated affluent market can still support more dentistry because of population growth, payer mix, and household income.

Current utilization data make that point brutally clear. In 2024, 58.1 percent of Americans with private dental insurance had a dental visit, compared with 32.5 percent with public coverage and 30.8 percent without insurance. Among working age adults, the gap was even wider. In 2025, 17 percent of working age adults reported going without needed dental care because of cost.

So the old case acceptance claim that patients decline treatment mainly because the dentist failed to “make it important enough” needs a reality check. Communication matters. Trust matters. Presentation matters. But sometimes the patient understands perfectly and still cannot afford the crown.

The Baby Boomer prediction was half right. The optimists were correct that older Americans would keep more teeth. CDC data show complete tooth loss among adults 65 and older falling from 27 percent in 1999 to 2004 to 17 percent in 2011 to 2016. More retained teeth can mean decades of additional preventive, restorative, periodontal, endodontic, and prosthetic care.

But “Baby Boomers are loaded” was never a serious population level economic model. In 2022, only 35.3 percent of seniors below the federal poverty level reported a recent dental exam or cleaning, compared with 80.5 percent of seniors above 400 percent of poverty. Same age group. Same country. Completely different dental markets.

Corporate dentistry was another area where the skeptics were prescient. Practice ownership among private practice dentists fell from 84.7 percent in 2005 to 72.5 percent in 2023. Among dentists under 30, ownership fell from 25.4 percent to just 8.8 percent. DSO affiliation more than doubled from 7.2 percent of dentists in 2015 to 16.1 percent in 2024. Among dentists less than five years out of dental school, 31 percent were DSO affiliated.

That is a strong PASS for anyone who predicted that chains and centralized scale would become formidable competitors. But “DSOs will kill private practice” also fails. Most dentists remain outside DSOs, and ownership often appears delayed rather than abandoned.

Student debt deserves the same discipline. ADEA reported average educational debt of about $187,394 among indebted dental graduates in 2008. Among indebted respondents in the Class of 2025, the average was $297,800. That sounds catastrophic until inflation enters the conversation. ADEA notes that the 2025 average was only 2 percent higher than in 2021 in nominal dollars, without adjusting for inflation. The better conclusion is not that debt has exploded continuously in real terms. It is that very large six figure debt has become entrenched while ownership occurs later and margins are tighter.

ADEA also exposes a revealing educational gap. Ninety two percent of 2025 graduating seniors said they felt ready to practice dentistry, but only 62 percent felt prepared to manage a successful business. That 30 point gap may explain more about delayed ownership than another lecture about crown preparations ever will.

The clinical sections of the 2008 thread aged much worse than the broad business principles. My old age based radiographic protocol would not reflect today’s ADA guidance. Current recommendations emphasize examination first, followed by imaging based on the patient’s history, risk, symptoms, previous radiographs, and the diagnostic question. The rule is not “take fewer X rays.” It is “take the right image for the right patient for the right reason.”

Periodontal classification changed too. The old Case Type I through V framework has been replaced by the 2017 World Workshop system using staging and grading, along with modern classifications for periodontal health, gingivitis, and peri implant disease. Staging asks how severe and complex the disease is today. Grading asks how aggressively it appears likely to progress.

Endodontics provides a useful example of what did survive. The American Association of Endodontists’ 2024 position statement continues to call dental dam isolation integral and essential for nonsurgical endodontic treatment. That principle aged very well. The old competitive discussion of how quickly somebody could complete molar endodontics did not. Modern AAE guidance emphasizes diagnosis, case selection, isolation, imaging, informed consent, disinfection, preservation of tooth structure, restoration, and knowing when to refer. A 30 minute root canal is not good because it took 30 minutes. Efficiency matters, but speed is not a quality metric.

Antibiotics also illustrate how standards evolve. Current ADA guidance recommends against systemic antibiotics for most pulpal and localized periapical conditions in immunocompetent adults when definitive treatment is available. The modern message is not that antibiotics never work. It is that antibiotics should not substitute for dentistry.

The larger lesson is simple: principles age better than products, formulas, and protocols. Rubber dam isolation, conservative treatment, good diagnosis, and knowing your limitations survived. Specific file systems, radiographic schedules, unsupported growth claims, and stopwatch contests did not deserve the same permanence.

The thread itself also deserves scrutiny as an information system. Hundreds of “mark” posts, “pure gold” endorsements, spectacular production stories, claims of extraordinary success, consultant testimonials, and dentists using their own practices as national economic evidence create powerful social proof. None of that requires dishonesty. It simply requires human beings.

The successful dentist posting a million dollar production story is visible. The failed startup may disappear. The consultant shows the client who doubled production, not necessarily everyone who did not. Without definitions, follow up, case selection, and denominators, anecdotes are not outcomes studies.

Avees’ best Cognitive Firewall question was essentially, “Who is telling me this, and what do they make money from?” That remains excellent. But conflict of interest should lower confidence, not automatically reverse the truth value of a claim. A salesman can be right. A disinterested dentist can be wrong. The evidence still has to settle it.

Nearly nineteen years later, the fairest verdict is that neither camp won. The pessimists correctly identified the Great Recession, financial sensitivity of dental demand, overhead pressure, student debt, insurance problems, oversaturated local markets, questionable equipment ROI, and the coming rise of corporate dentistry. They were wrong to turn those pressures into a prediction that dentistry itself was becoming a bad profession.

The optimists correctly predicted continued demand, improved technology, longer tooth retention, tremendous clinical innovation, and the ability of well run practices to prosper. They were wrong about an inevitable national dentist shortage, underestimated DSOs and reimbursement pressure, and too often confused exceptional personal success with evidence about the average dentist.

My own 2008 business philosophy aged better than my formulas. Labor matters. Delegation matters. Team quality matters. Clinical competence matters. Continuing education matters. Capacity matters. Location matters. Conservative diagnosis matters. Knowing your numbers matters. Those principles remain. The exact 80 percent variable cost split, universal staffing ratios, age based radiographic rules, old periodontal case types, unsupported procedure growth rates, and stopwatch dentistry belong in 2008.

So is dentistry still a good career in 2026? Yes, by most ordinary measures. Dentists remain highly compensated, national dental spending reached $189 billion in 2024, the population is aging while keeping more teeth, and demand for oral healthcare is not disappearing. But the traditional owner operated GP model is unquestionably more complicated. Real GP income has been under pressure, reimbursement has lagged costs, practice ownership occurs later, DSOs are larger, staffing is difficult, and affordability limits how much clinical need turns into paying demand.

The real lesson from 2008 is not that the pessimists were right or the optimists were right. It is that universal claims about “dentistry” are usually too crude to be useful. The better question is the one hiding underneath the old debate: Compared with what, according to whose data, in what market, for what kind of dentist, and who benefits if I believe the answer? Nearly nineteen years later, that question has passed the test of time.

Join the Conversation!



Is Dentistry Still a Good Career in 2026? What Dentaltown’s 2008 Predictions Got Right and Wrong

Economic Cycle and Dental Demand

NBER Business Cycle Dating Committee Announcement, December 1, 2008 https://www.nber.org/news/business-cycle-dating-committee-announcement-december-1-2008

NBER Business Cycle Dating Committee Announcement, September 20, 2010 https://www.nber.org/news/business-cycle-dating-committee-announcement-september-20-2010

ADA HPI: Dentist Earnings and Busyness in the U.S. https://www.ada.org/-/media/project/ada-organization/ada/ada-org/files/resources/research/hpi/hpigraphic_1220_1.pdf

The Effect of the Great Recession on the Demand for General Oral Health Care and Orthodontic Care https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30826000/

Dentist Income, Practice Economics, and the Dental Market

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Dentists, Occupational Outlook Handbook https://www.bls.gov/ooh/healthcare/dentists.htm

ADA HPI: Dental Practice Research

https://www.ada.org/resources/research/health-policy-institute/dental-practice-research

ADA HPI: The State of the U.S. Dental Economy, Second Quarter 2026 https://www.ada.org/-/media/project/ada-organization/ada/ada-org/files/resources/research/hpi/state_us_dental_economy_q22026.pdf

ADA HPI: Economic Outlook and Emerging Issues in Dentistry, Fourth Quarter 2024 and 2025 Outlook https://www.ada.org/-/media/project/ada-organization/ada/ada-org/files/resources/research/hpi/dec2024_hpi_economic_outlook_dentistry_slides.pdf

ADA HPI: National Dental Expenditures https://www.ada.org/resources/research/health-policy-institute/dental-care-market/national-dental-expenses

ADA: How to Purchase a Dental Practice With Confidence https://www.ada.org/resources/careers/career-planning/how-to-purchase-with-confidence

Dentist Supply, Ownership, DSOs, and Staffing

ADA HPI: The U.S. Dentist Workforce, 2025 Update https://www.ada.org/-/media/project/ada-organization/ada/ada-org/files/resources/research/hpi/us_dentist_workforce_2025.pdf

ADA HPI: Dental Education https://www.ada.org/resources/research/health-policy-institute/dental-education

ADEA: Dentists of Tomorrow 2025 https://www.adea.org/home/publications/research-and-data/graduating-oral-health-students/dentists-of-tomorrow-2025

HRSA: Designated Health Professional Shortage Areas Statistics

https://data.hrsa.gov/Default/GenerateHPSAQuarterlyReport

ADA HPI: Dental Hygienist Shortage https://www.ada.org/resources/research/health-policy-institute/dentist-workforce/dental-hygienist-shortage

Dental Utilization, Affordability, and the Aging Population

ADA HPI: National Trends in Dental Care Use, Dental Insurance Coverage, and Cost Barriers  https://www.ada.org/-/media/project/ada-organization/ada/ada-org/files/resources/research/hpi/national_trends_dental_use_benefits_barriers_2026.pdf

CDC: Total Tooth Loss Decreased in Adults Aged 65 or Older https://www.cdc.gov/oral-health/php/infographics/total-tooth-loss-decreased-adults-65-older.html

CDC National Center for Health Statistics: Dental Care Among Adults Age 65 and Older, United States, 2022 https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db500.htm

Current Clinical Standards and Guidelines

ADA: 2026 Recommendations for the Use of Dental Imaging https://adanews.ada.org/ada-news/2026/january/new-ada-recommendations-confirm-dental-imaging-most-effectively-used-in-moderation/

American Academy of Periodontology: 2017 Classification of Periodontal and Peri-implant Diseases and Conditions https://www.perio.org/research-science/2017-classification-of-periodontal-and-peri-implant-diseases-and-conditions/

American Association of Endodontists: Dental Dams Position Statement https://www.aae.org/specialty/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/DentalDams_PositionStatement_v2.pdf

American Association of Endodontists: Clinical Guidelines and Position Statements https://www.aae.org/specialty/clinical-resources/guidelines-position-statements/

ADA: Antibiotics for Dental Pain and Swelling https://www.ada.org/resources/research/science/evidence-based-dental-research/antibiotics-for-dental-pain-and-swelling


Views: 41
Sponsors
Townie Perks