Atraumatic Tooth Extraction: Dr. David Fyffe’s Xpanders and the Science of Bone Preservation
Every dentist knows how quickly a fractured root tip can turn a routine extraction into an unexpected surgical procedure. The appointment runs long, the patient becomes anxious, and preserving the socket for a future implant may become more challenging. Dr. David D. Fyffe, DDS, has spent much of his career developing instruments to make dentistry easier and more predictable. A 1983 dental graduate and founder of ArtCraft Dental, which traces its origins to 1994, he developed Xpanders in 2013 after decades of clinical experience and experimentation with extraction instruments. He has also been a Townie since 2004, contributing more than 1,387 posts to the Dentaltown community. His company’s philosophy says it all: “For Dentists, By a Dentist.”
Xpanders are specialized dental elevators designed to increase tooth mobility before forceps are applied. Their distinctive double-pronged tips establish contact near the alveolar crest and cervical tooth surface. Controlled twisting produces lateral tooth movement and socket expansion, progressively loosening the tooth before delivery. While periotomes primarily separate periodontal ligament fibers, Xpanders use a different mechanical approach to achieve controlled luxation. Four instrument configurations accommodate anterior and posterior teeth. The design is intended to make extractions more efficient while minimizing unnecessary force and trauma to surrounding tissues, considerations that become particularly valuable when preserving socket anatomy for future implant placement.
Research involving other extraction instruments provides useful context for understanding the potential benefits of controlled tooth mobilization. In a 2025 randomized clinical trial involving 100 patients with single-rooted teeth, Swati Sahu and colleagues reported average extraction times of 4.97 minutes using a universal periotome compared with 11.47 minutes using conventional instrumentation. The periotome group also experienced less gingival injury and postoperative pain. In a separate 2022 randomized trial involving 48 teeth, Mohammed Alraqibah and colleagues found that periotomes averaged 4.96 minutes compared with 7.96 minutes for ultrasonic piezotomes, with less reported pain during extraction. Neither trial evaluated Xpanders, but both illustrate how instrument design and extraction technique can influence clinical efficiency and patient comfort.
Preserving the socket during extraction also raises an important biological question: how much bone remains after healing? A 2021 systematic review by Emilio Couso-Queiruga and colleagues examined 28 studies and found that naturally healing nonmolar extraction sites lost an average of 2.54 millimeters of ridge width and 1.65 millimeters of midfacial height on radiographic assessment. Much of this remodeling occurs because the alveolar bone changes after the tooth and its periodontal ligament are removed. Even a carefully performed extraction cannot completely prevent that process. In the 2019 Naples Consensus meta-analysis of 14 randomized clinical trials, Shayan Barootchi and colleagues found that alveolar ridge preservation procedures reduced horizontal ridge loss by an average of 1.95 millimeters and midbuccal height loss by 1.62 millimeters compared with unassisted healing. These findings reinforce the complementary roles of careful extraction technique and appropriate socket preservation.
For dentists planning immediate or delayed implants, treatment planning begins before the tooth is removed. Root anatomy, facial bone thickness, periodontal destruction, infection, and the proposed restoration all influence the surgical approach. Instruments that provide controlled tooth mobility can be useful in managing extraction forces, particularly when surrounding bone is thin or compromised. Equally important is explaining to patients that an uncomplicated extraction does not guarantee preservation of ridge dimensions during healing. Socket grafting may still be indicated, depending on the anatomy and restorative objectives.
ArtCraft Dental has received very favorable feedback from dentists using Xpanders, and Fyffe’s experience as both a practicing clinician and instrument inventor brings an interesting perspective to the evolution of extraction techniques. His work reflects a tradition of innovation that has shaped dentistry for generations: clinicians identify recurring problems in the operatory, experiment with different solutions, and develop instruments intended to improve everyday patient care. Continued clinical experience and comparative research can help establish which techniques offer the greatest advantages for particular teeth and clinical situations.
After more than four decades in dentistry, Fyffe continues to demonstrate how practical ideas can originate at the dental chair and become instruments used by colleagues. His Xpanders are another contribution to the ongoing effort to make tooth extraction more controlled, efficient, and conservative.
Have Xpanders changed the way you approach tooth extractions?
Join the Conversation!