The True History of Halloween: From Samhain and All Hallows’ Eve to Trick or Treating

Posted: October 30, 2026
By Howard Farran, DDS, MBA

The True History of Halloween: From Samhain and All Hallows’ Eve to Trick or Treating

Every October, Americans cover their homes with witches, skeletons and ghosts while children dress as monsters and roam neighborhoods collecting candy. It looks about as far from a Christian holy day as imaginable. Yet hidden inside the word “Halloween” is a word meaning holy, the same word preserved in one of Christianity’s most familiar prayers: “Hallowed be thy name.”

Halloween comes from All Hallows’ Eve, the evening before All Hallows’ Day, better known as All Saints’ Day. In Middle English, a “hallow” was a holy person or saint. As a verb, “hallow” meant to make holy, sanctify or honor as sacred. That is the meaning of “hallowed” in the Lord’s Prayer. The connection between Halloween and “Hallowed be thy name” is real. Both descend from the same ancient family of words associated with holiness.

The name reaches deep into medieval English. October 31 was described as “alle halwe eue” around 1300. In Scotland, All Hallows’ Eve became Hallowe’en as “even” was shortened to “e’en.” By the 16th century, recognizable forms of Halloween were already in use. The greeting “hello,” sometimes spelled “hallo,” is unrelated. It developed from calls such as hollo and halloo used to attract someone’s attention.

The name is easier to trace than the holiday. Popular histories often force Halloween into one of two stories. One says it is fundamentally the ancient Celtic festival of Samhain that Christianity later appropriated. The other portrays it as a Christian observance later covered with secular customs. History is messier.

Samhain was an ancient Gaelic festival marking the transition from summer into the darker part of the year. The American Folklife Center at the Library of Congress considers a historical connection between Samhain and Halloween strong, although some popular claims about the festival are less certain. Folklorist Stephen Winick specifically questions the familiar assertion that Samhain was unquestionably the “Celtic New Year.” That interpretation became popular much later, while the surviving historical evidence is less definitive.

Christianity added another layer. The Western Church eventually celebrated All Saints’ Day, or All Hallows, on November 1 and All Souls’ Day on November 2. Together with October 31, these observances formed a period centered on saints, souls, death and remembrance. As Christianity spread through Celtic lands, older seasonal beliefs encountered Christian practices and the traditions mingled. The Library of Congress describes Halloween as having roots in both Christian and pre-Christian traditions.

That distinction matters because the origin of the name is different from the origin of every Halloween custom. The name is Christian. Some supernatural folklore has older Celtic and European roots. Medieval Christianity contributed customs surrounding prayers for the dead. In England and Ireland, poor people went door to door around All Saints’ and All Souls’ Days receiving “soul cakes” in exchange for prayers for deceased relatives. Children eventually joined the practice, known as souling, one of several ancestors of modern trick or treating.

Jack-o’-lanterns arrived through another route. People in Ireland and Scotland carved frightening faces into turnips and other vegetables, with Irish folklore connecting the custom to the legend of Stingy Jack. Immigrants carried these traditions to America, where the native pumpkin proved larger and much easier to carve.

Immigration transformed Halloween in the United States. Irish immigrants, particularly those arriving during and after the Great Famine, helped spread Halloween customs across the country. By the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the holiday had also become notorious for pranks and vandalism. Communities responded with parties, games and supervised celebrations.

Then America reinvented Halloween again. Mass-produced costumes allowed children to become superheroes, princesses and movie characters alongside ghosts and witches. Trick or treating spread, candy became inseparable from the holiday, and Hollywood supplied generations of vampires, monsters and horror villains. By the 1950s, Halloween was increasingly centered on children, families and neighborhoods. Today it is predominantly secular, commercial and international.

So asking whether Halloween is pagan or Christian creates a false choice. Samhain contributed an ancient seasonal and supernatural inheritance. Medieval Christianity supplied All Hallows, All Souls, prayers for the dead and the name Halloween itself. Irish and Scottish folklore crossed the Atlantic, while American immigration, neighborhoods, retailers and popular culture created much of the holiday we recognize today.

The strangest part of the story has been sitting in the word all along. Beneath the witches, skeletons, haunted houses and candy, Halloween means All Hallows’ Eve, the evening before the feast honoring all the saints. The “hallow” in Halloween and the “hallowed” in “Hallowed be thy name” share the same linguistic heritage, both carrying an ancient idea of holiness.

How did a word rooted in holiness become the name of our biggest night of ghosts and monsters?

Join the Conversation!



The True History of Halloween: From Samhain and All Hallows’ Eve to Trick or Treating

Etymology

Online Etymology Dictionary. “Halloween: Etymology, Origin & Meaning of the Name” https://www.etymonline.com/word/Halloween

Online Etymology Dictionary. “Hallow: Etymology, Origin & Meaning” https://www.etymonline.com/word/hallow

Library of Congress

Library of Congress. “Halloween & Día de Muertos Resources” https://guides.loc.gov/halloween/

American Folklife Center, Library of Congress. “Welcome to Folklife Today, and…Happy Halloween!” https://blogs.loc.gov/folklife/2013/10/welcome-to-folklife-today/

Library of Congress. “Today in History: October 31” https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/october-31/

Halloween History and Traditions

History. “Halloween: Origins, Traditions and History” https://www.history.com/articles/history-of-halloween

History. “How Halloween Has Changed Over the Centuries” https://www.history.com/articles/halloween-timeline


Views: 42
Sponsors
Townie Perks