Five Pounds of Dental Gold: What Dentists Should Know Before Selling Scrap Crowns

Posted: October 28, 2026
By Howard Farran, DDS, MBA

Five Pounds of Dental Gold: What Dentists Should Know Before Selling Scrap Crowns

A Dentaltown member recently described accumulating roughly five pounds of old crowns, bridges and PFMs over about 15 years in a geriatric practice. Much of the material appeared to be high noble, with relatively little porcelain or tooth structure remaining. With gold trading near $4,000 an ounce, the obvious question was what the pile might actually be worth.

The first temptation is to multiply five pounds by the spot price of gold. Five ordinary pounds equal about 72.9 troy ounces. At roughly $4,050 per troy ounce, five pounds of pure gold would be worth close to $295,000. That is an interesting ceiling, but dental scrap is never that simple. Restorations can contain gold, palladium, platinum, silver, copper and other metals, while PFMs may still carry porcelain and some restorations may contain little precious metal at all.

Even so, a five pound collection dominated by high noble restorations could represent serious money. If the entire pile averaged 40% gold by weight, the contained gold alone would be worth roughly $118,000 at a $4,050 spot price. At 60%, the theoretical value rises to about $177,000. At 75%, it approaches $221,000. Platinum, palladium and silver could add more. These are illustrations, not appraisals, but they explain how a bucket of old crowns can quietly become a six figure business asset.

One of the biggest mistakes is assuming that high noble means high gold content. According to the ADA, a high noble alloy contains at least 60% noble metal by weight, with at least 40% gold. The rest may include palladium, platinum, silver, copper and other metals. A restoration can therefore qualify as high noble without resembling 18 karat jewelry. Two crowns that look nearly identical can have very different compositions and very different scrap values.

PFMs make visual guessing even less reliable. The metal underneath the porcelain may be high noble, noble, titanium, nickel chromium, cobalt chromium or another alloy. That is why reputable refiners melt and assay the material instead of simply weighing a jar of crowns. Scientific Metals describes a process in which the scrap is weighed, documented, melted at temperatures above 3,000 degrees Fahrenheit and converted into a homogeneous molten mass. A representative sample is then analyzed for gold, platinum, palladium and silver before a settlement is calculated.

Argen’s published terms make the economics even clearer. Its settlement depends on processed weight, assay percentage, an accountability rate for each payable metal, the applicable market price and refining charges. That matters because a refiner can report that a sample contains a certain amount of gold without necessarily paying for 100% of every ounce detected. Dentists should ask what percentage of recovered gold, platinum, palladium and silver is actually payable, what fees are deducted, which market price determines settlement, whether a written assay is provided and whether the settlement can be rejected.

Scientific Metals publishes several case studies in which dentists reportedly received materially higher settlements after rejecting lower offers elsewhere and sending the same material or ingot for another assay. The differences in some examples were 30% or more. These are company selected case studies, not independent controlled comparisons, so they do not prove that one refiner will always outperform another. They do show how expensive opaque deductions, commissions and low cash offers can become.

The idea of splitting five pounds into many random half pound batches sounds like good risk management, but it can create a bad comparison. Dental scrap is heterogeneous. One bag may contain several high gold bridges while another contains palladium rich PFMs or lower value alloys. If two refiners receive different mixtures, their payouts tell you little about which company actually returned more of the underlying value. A small pilot shipment can still make sense to evaluate communication, documentation and settlement procedures before committing the rest.

Shipping may be the most overlooked risk. Garfield Refining states that shipments using its labels are insured up to $75,000. That may be adequate for an ordinary scrap shipment and potentially inadequate for five pounds of unusually valuable high noble material. Argen bases insurance on the recent average value of similar material, which may also differ from the eventual assay value of an unusually rich collection. Before shipping a potentially six figure asset, get the insured dollar amount in writing and understand exactly when coverage begins.

Ownership deserves the same attention. The CDC says extracted teeth may be returned to patients upon request, but its guidance addresses infection control rather than nationwide property law. State law and office policies may matter. Argen’s contract goes further by requiring the person submitting scrap to warrant that the material belongs to that person and is free of third party claims. A practical office policy is to address removed precious metal restorations at the time of treatment, offer them back to the patient when appropriate, and document acceptance or declination.

Taxes are another area where casual assumptions can be expensive. IRS Publication 525 explains that receiving property instead of cash can still create taxable income based on fair market value. Publication 334 similarly explains that businesses generally must report income even when payment arrives as property rather than money. Receiving gold coins or bullion instead of a check does not automatically make the transaction tax free, and the absence of a Form 1099 does not determine whether income is reportable.

Exactly how years of accumulated dental scrap should be treated for tax purposes can depend on ownership, prior deductions, entity structure, accounting method and any remaining tax basis. That is a CPA question, especially if the settlement reaches six figures. The records should be preserved. Photograph and weigh the collection, retain the shipping documentation, assay report, settlement statement and payment records, and give the complete file to the practice accountant.

Gold prices will continue moving, but trying to pick the perfect day may matter less than dentists think. At roughly $4,050 per ounce, a 10 percentage point difference in actual gold content across five pounds represents almost $30,000 of theoretical value. A poor assay or unfavorable settlement could cost just as much or more. Composition, accountability rates, fees and insurance may matter more than whether gold moves a few hundred dollars between shipment and settlement.

Five pounds of predominantly high noble dental restorations could plausibly be worth well over $100,000. Treat a large collection like a valuable business asset. Verify ownership, demand a transparent four metal assay, understand every deduction, confirm shipping insurance and involve your CPA before settlement. Color and weight can start the conversation, but chemistry gets the final vote.

How much dental gold is sitting unnoticed in practices across America?

Join the Conversation!



Five Pounds of Dental Gold: What Dentists Should Know Before Selling Scrap Crowns

Dental Scrap Refining and Valuation

Scientific Metals: Dental Scrap Refining https://www.scientificmetals.com/tpd-dental-scrap-refining

Scientific Metals: Dental Scrap Refining Case Studies https://www.scientificmetals.com/case-studies

Argen: Refining Terms and Conditions https://argen.com/refining-conditions

Garfield Refining: Dental Scrap Refining https://www.garfieldrefining.com/industries/dental-lab/

Kitco: Live Gold Spot Price https://www.kitco.com/charts/gold

Dental Alloys and Restorative Materials

American Dental Association: Glossary of Dental Terms https://www.ada.org/publications/cdt/glossary-dental-terms

American Dental Association: Materials for Indirect Restorations https://www.ada.org/resources/ada-library/oral-health-topics/materials-for-indirect-restorations

Extracted Teeth, Ownership and Infection Control

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Best Practices for Handling Extracted Teeth https://www.cdc.gov/dental-infection-control/hcp/dental-ipc-faqs/extracted-teeth.html

Taxation and Business Income

Internal Revenue Service: Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income https://www.irs.gov/publications/p525

Internal Revenue Service: Publication 334, Tax Guide for Small Business https://www.irs.gov/publications/p334


Views: 37
Sponsors
Townie Perks