Electric vs. Air
Electric vs. Air
From our international perspective at A-dec, we're able to
observe an interesting contrast in regional preferences for handpieces.
Because most American dentists are trained with airdriven
handpieces, while many European dentists work more
with electric handpieces, we see many instances where transitioning
from one to the other is a real challenge. I have seen many
American dentists try to use an electric handpiece with the same
technique they use with an air-driven, only to be frustrated.
The fact is both air-driven and electric handpieces are
important to have in a modern operatory, but they require very
different techniques, and each tool lends itself to different
applications. Because of its consistent power and the fact that it
uses a gear train to deliver rotation through a chuck, an electric
handpiece is excellent for creating very precise, smooth margins
that help reduce the risk of microleakage. On the other hand,
an air-driven handpiece has the advantage of offering a great
tactile feel that is important in applications such as caries
removal. When dealing with a softened carious lesion, being
too heavy handed with a handpiece can result in unnecessary
removal of healthy tissue, so a strong tactile feel is especially
important. These examples illustrate why it is important for
dentists to have both types of handpieces in the operatory, and
to be skilled in the use of each.
||Think of it as a tiny milling machine.
Place the bur and guide it.
|Use a light touch and tactile sense.
||- Never loses torque
- Creates precise margins
|- Better tactile feel
- Better visualization
||- Crown preps
- Crown removals
|- Caries removal
- Minimally invasive techniques
The Advantages of Integrating Handpieces
We all know that chairside real estate is incredibly valuable.
Just about every dental office storage space is littered
with tabletop devices that are no longer being used because
they're obsolete or they are not providing enough value to earn
a place in the operatory. The importance of space in the treatment
room is one major reason why it's so helpful to integrate
your handpieces into your chair system. Not only does this
reduce clutter from extra boxes, but the right integrated system
can also help make future upgrades smoother, as controllers
and handpieces are designed for compatibility with
both past and future models. A reliable manufacturer understands
the value of the investment dentists make in their
equipment, and works to maximize that value with tools that
are designed for future flexibility.
Busting Handpiece Myths
Myth #1: "Lube-free" turbines are worry-free.
Who wouldn't want a tool that requires less maintenance
than its competitors? The concept of "lube-free" turbines certainly
sounds attractive, but the truth is it's just a marketing
technique. Years ago manufacturers started promoting handpieces
with ceramic bearings as lube-free, in contrast to steel
bearings. Today though, both ceramic and steel bearings perform
very similarly, but some ceramic products are offered with
two warranties - one period of time if you lube the handpiece
(as you would with a steel bearing), and half that time if you
don't lube it. So to use a lube-free handpiece is essentially to pay
more money for a product that needs less maintenance, but also
doesn't last as long.
Myth #2: Hand-spraying is the cheapest way to
The lube-free concept shines a light on the perceived hassle of
lubricating handpieces. Some dentists have determined that it's cheapest to pay an assistant to lubricate handpieces with a spray
can, only to find later the inconsistencies and material waste of this
practice result in no savings at all. There are also health drawbacks
for the assistant who has to breathe the air in the maintenance area.
Handpieces can be damaged from having either too much or
too little oil, as both problems result in increased friction in the
handpiece and additional wear. Relying on human beings to perform
lubrication correctly and consistently is a real risk. How accurately
could you spray a can for one or two seconds, dozens of times
a day? Human nature is such that fatigue invariably sets in and the
work is done less consistently over time. Even if you did have one
assistant who performed lubrication perfectly every time, what are
the odds that assistant will stay with your practice forever?
Instead, using an automated system for lubrication makes the process simple and automatic and can help save money in repair costs, as well as wasting less oil. A-dec's Assistina 301 Plus maintenance system, for example, costs less than two cents per cycle and provides consistent and precise cleaning and lubrication. The system takes just 35 seconds per cycle, needs no electricity and has universal adapters that accept most brands of handpieces, motors and attachments. Several other automated systems are available, and regardless of which one is used, they are better than lubing by hand.
Myth #3: A warranty is the true mark of quality.
In general, newer model handpieces have a life expectancy of 18
to 24 months, while older models last closer to 12 months. While
this might not seem long compared to other pieces of equipment
in your office, it is actually more than double the lifespan of handpieces
30 years ago.
A warranty can help provide some guidance on what an
expected lifespan is for a handpiece, but dentists should also understand
that warranties are part of the marketing message for a product
just like any other claim on the packaging. There are businesses
like RadioShack that have opened up completely new revenue
streams just by selling warranties. When examining handpieces and
warranties, dentists should keep a manufacturer's reputation in
mind and understand that a reliable company will back its product
whether it falls within a warranty term or not.
Myth #4: Not enough torque? Just crank the air pressure.
Too little air pressure in a handpiece will result in a loss of
torque, meaning you won't get the cutting efficiency you need.
With too much air pressure, on the other hand, you'll have cutting efficiency but also a lot of noise, as well as premature wear on the
bearings in the handpiece.
In the past, some dentists using older handpieces might have
found that cranking their air pressure way up was the only way to
get enough power, but with modern designs this isn't really necessary.
Thanks to CAD/CAM technologies, turbines in today's
handpieces offer significant efficiency improvements over models
that are just five or 10 years old. With 3D modeling and rapid prototyping,
handpieces today are tested and tweaked to perfection
before they hit the production line. Once there, simplified and
precise manufacturing results in a greatly improved end product.
With a modern handpiece, relying on the old method of turning
up the air pressure for extra torque can easily shorten the lifespan
of the product. To avoid creating a headache for yourself, read
the instructions for your handpiece and set the air pressure accordingly.
The recommended level has been carefully thought out by
the manufacturer to optimize the handpiece's performance and
longevity. (This is also another good argument for having both
electric and air-driven handpieces. With an electric handpiece
nearby, you'll have all the torque you need.)
Myth #5: I can do implants with my general restorative motor.
If you've heard from colleagues or a manufacturer that the general restorative motor on your handpiece is implant capable, you might be running with the wrong crowd. The FDA has recently been paying more attention to claims like these and asking manufacturers to set the record straight. The facts are that a general motor doesn't have enough power for implant placement, and there are additional safety concerns related to the need for sterile irrigant and for coolant air to be shut off. When placing implants, stick to an implant motor with 5Ncm of torque.